Featured The Holder Premium Thread

Isn't that the second time you've done that to me?

 

Log in or Sign up to hide this ad.

I havent kept score but, i doubt its gonna matter. Paddy would rather cherry the variety for $50 im sure, and he probably did.
I heard something about a cough *cheapskate* cough cough

 

Well it seems that no one came remotely close to the actual retail price paid! Thus I believe that the point should be given to me for stumping the players ,and I should be able to post another coin.
What does the rules committee say?
As the quesses are hundreds off...like double +....... actual price paid....

 

Glad, I went the lowest! should make me the winner then.

 

The guessing the 15 years ago price threw everyone way off

 

Let’s hear the price and see who was closest. Then I’ll make a ruling

Edit: Grandma fell asleep playing so much bingo

 

I never clicked on this thread before because I didn't know what it was. Out of curiosity this morning I did and I can see that this will be addicting!

 

Oh yeah... wait until you win a round and have tp pick something from your collection to put out there... yes, it's been a lot of fun!

 

Actual Retail Price Paid was $700.00 USD None of you even if you double your guesses were even in the neighborhood.

 

Damn... the seller saw the registry set calling...

 

Oh no

 

So was it already graded back then? If so, what holder was it in back then?

And I'll make an exception and award the point to you @Paddy54
Let's try and keep the next entry to a purchase from the last 5 years

Point totals:
ddddd - 6.5 Points
baseball21 - 6 Points
Beefer518 - 3 Points
Mainebill - 3 Points
jtlee321 - 3 Points
Burton Strauss III - 3 Points
Paddy54 - 3 Points
Pickin and Grinin - 2 Points
heavycam.monstervam - 2 Points
jwitten - 1 Point
Bman33 - 1 Point
jpcienkus - 1 Point
BlackBeard_Thatch - 1 Point
KSorbo - 1 Point

 

Granny said she like "Heavy" to take her roller blading down Santa Monica Blvd.

 

Burton I will pass the honor to you.... you said you got something special to post.
Heavy....granny said don't forget to bring some poly-grip she doesn't want to hit a bump and have the dentures chattering down the boulevard.

 

@Burton Strauss III let's see that ACG

 

OK...

McKinney 1917 $1 gold commemorative, purchased: 3/9/2018 at the ANA NMS.

It’s Accugrade. It’s a PhotoSlab. It’s Accugrade #59, which I’ve never heard of before. 65, 91, several other #s sure. It’s a gold commemorative. So I had to buy it. Just had to.


The actual gold weight is 0.0484 oz, with a Melt value of $64.15 (3/12/2018).

Accugrade A3-63c... (Full strike, dull surface)

oh and for giggles, one of the labels is upside down!


The coin isn't bad, although I doubt is an MS63 (I really have no idea how to grade these):





Price wise, MS-63 is an interesting beast…

MS63

$875 ….. NGC price guide (https://www.ngccoin.com/coin-explor...926-pscid-72/1917-g1-mckinley-ms-coinid-17455)

“Recent” auctions: (2017) 517, (2016) 646, 470, (2015) 564, 541

$770 …… PCGS price guide (http://www.pcgscoinfacts.com/Coin/Detail/7455)

“Recent” auctions: (2017) 595, 525, (2016) 999, 521, 541

$682 ….. CDN CPG retail price guide (https://www.greysheet.com/coin-prices/item?id=7455&CatalogId=1)


MS-62

$785 ….. NGC

“Recent” auctions: none since 2009

$770 ….. PCGS

“Recent” auctions: (2017) 435, (2016) 470

$618 ….. CDN CPG


XF-40

$535 ….. NGC

$480 ….. PCGS

$494 ….. CDN CPG


eBay sold

$255 ….. AU Details (cleaned)

$325 ….. NGC AU Details (improperly cleaned)

$450 ….. Circulated

$351 ….. Uncirculated (Great Southern Coins)


So, what did I pay? Cash if it helps.

 

I'll say $350
(raw AU/borderline UNC price)
...and I'll add that would be a good value!

 

400

 

525

 

$480