Puck "Cents"

Discussion in 'Bullion Investing' started by Phil Ham, May 11, 2013.

  1. 1970 Silver Art

    1970 Silver Art Silver Art Bar Collector

    Update (11-9-2018): I sold one of the two 2017-P George Rogers Clark 5-oz Uncirculated pucks on ebay that I bought a week ago. I sold it for $229. I will keep the other one for myself.
     
    Phil Ham, halvessearcher and longarm like this.
  2. Avatar

    Guest User Guest



    to hide this ad.
  3. Phil Ham

    Phil Ham Hamster

    Frederick Douglas has officially sold out with a mintage of 17,678. Block Island has shipped from the mint. Cumberland Island is getting little demand at 14,282 sold.
     
    McBlzr and halvessearcher like this.
  4. Phil Ham

    Phil Ham Hamster

    The Block Island National Wildlife Refuge puck went on sale in November 2018. The mint sold 13,501 in the first of week of sales. Puck sales have been very week in the past few months and the release of Block Island didn't seem to give the other pucks much of a bump. Although the program is running out of gas, I do like the design of this one as well as the others from 2018. Here is some information on the puck from the mint website.

    Block Island National Wildlife Refuge is located 12 miles off the southern coast of mainland Rhode Island and sits on a terminal moraine, shaped by glacial till deposits, creating rolling dunes. Covering 133 acres, the refuge is distinctive because the staff works closely with other conservation organizations in an effort to protect the land. One partner, the Town of New Shoreham, operates the adjoining North Lighthouse, the island’s first lighthouse built in 1867. It has an interpretive display highlighting the importance of barrier beach habitat and the protection of the piping plover and other migratory shorebirds.

    Block Island National Wildlife Refuge is a critical migratory bird stopover point on the Atlantic coast. Fruit-bearing shrubs provide essential food for the species of birds that come to rest there. These wild lands are also known internationally for spectacular bird watching and provide a breath-taking walk along the barrier beaches.


    Block Island v2.JPG
     
  5. Phil Ham

    Phil Ham Hamster

    With the release of the Block Island puck, I thought it would be a good time to update the market values versus their mintages. Although the Rhode Island puck had a slightly higher initial demand than its Georgia counterpart, it certainly wasn't a robust opening week. Cumberland Island has yet to reach 14,500 in sales despite two months of sales. Seven pucks are on sale at the mint (two from early last year) with little buyer interest. You can drive one off the lot and expect a 10% reduction in value and later, buyer's remorse. In addition, there is little demand for the sold out pucks on the secondary market. The low price of silver is reducing demand while spurring ASE bullion sales. Meanwhile, puck values are declining faster than Grant took Vicksburg. Considering silver near $14/ounce, the mint should lower the price in 2019 to keep this program on life support. It is going the way of the presidential dollars. The chart and graph tell the gloomy story.

    upload_2018-11-25_11-5-29.png

    upload_2018-11-25_11-6-3.png
     
    halvessearcher likes this.
  6. Phil Ham

    Phil Ham Hamster

    The US mint webpage shows the Ozark puck (17,693) and the Pictured Rocks (17,747) puck as unavailable. Considering their mintages, I believe that they will move to sold out very soon. Pictured Rocks will be the first sell out of 2018 while Effigy Mounds will be the only puck remaining from 2017.
     
  7. Phil Ham

    Phil Ham Hamster

    Sales will end for Effigy Mounds on 31 December. Ozark and Pictured Rocks remain unavailable and probably only available from returns. Sales for the other pucks were up slightly, probably due to Christmas.
     
    SLACKACTION likes this.
  8. They got a bump from the free budget shipping maybe. lol Cool 5 buck savings.
     
  9. 1970 Silver Art

    1970 Silver Art Silver Art Bar Collector

    I sold the 2nd George Rogers "P" today on ebay for a decent profit. I do not regret it because I am planning to use the proceeds to buy that Apollo 5-oz coin that is supposed to come out on Janaury 24, 2019.
     
  10. -jeffB

    -jeffB Greshams LEO Supporter

    The Effigy Mounds design on a puck must look like a quilted pillow.
     
  11. Phil Ham

    Phil Ham Hamster

    It isn't one of my favorite designs.
     
  12. longarm

    longarm Just another Jewish Carpenter

    Bullion mintage for 2018
    Pictured Rocks 30k
    Apostle Islands
    30k
    Voyageurs 30k
    Cumberland Island 52.5k
    Block Island 80k
     
  13. Phil Ham

    Phil Ham Hamster

    The Lowell puck went on sale in February 2019, and the mint sold 12,734 in the first week. Other pucks continue to have weak sales and the release of Lowell didn't seem to garner much hype for the puck program. Personally, I like the design of this one. Here is some information on the puck from the mint website.

    The reverse depicts a mill girl working at a power loom with its prominent circular bobbin battery. A view of Lowell, including the Boott Mill clock tower is seen through the window. Inscriptions include "LOWELL," "MASSACHUSETTS," "2019," and "E PLURIBUS UNUM." Lowell National Historical Park preserves and interprets the role of Lowell, MA, in the Industrial Revolution, archiving the history of the human story in addition to the industry processes and cultural environment of the time. The era was also defined, in part, by the “Mill Girls,” young women who were recruited to work in the mills, where they earned cash wages and lived in supervised, company-owned boarding houses. They became an important voice for labor by advocating for better working conditions, supporting abolition, and embracing education.

    Lowell (2).JPG
     
    medjoy and SLACKACTION like this.
  14. statequarterguy

    statequarterguy Love Pucks

    Mine arrives tomorrow. I still like these for the long term, the weaker the sales now, the better for the long run. Looks like the bullion versions are gaining in popularity, why 5 SAE's when you can buy one of the pucks for about the same price and a fraction of the mintage.
     
    medjoy likes this.
  15. Phil Ham

    Phil Ham Hamster

    I like the pucks too but not sure that they will appreciate in value. I just like the size, designs, and the history. I drive through Lowell often when I return to my childhood home in Maine. I never knew that they had a national park. Perhaps I will visit it the next time through. I'm also looking forward to the curved Apollo 11 puck. I see that the mint has changed my order status to processing and billed my credit card.
     
    medjoy likes this.
  16. Phil Ham

    Phil Ham Hamster

    The Lowell puck has been released for over a month with extremely low sales; just 13,395 pucks sold. Five pucks are on sale at the mint (four from 2018 along with the Massachusetts offering) with receiving little interest from the collector's universe. Puck values increased in value slightly since the last update in November 2018. It is probably related to the rise in silver from about $14/ounce in November to nearly $15.50/ounce today. With the low sales of the pucks, the mint may want to consider a lower price to pump up some demand. The chart and graph tell the story.
    upload_2019-3-23_12-22-4.png

    upload_2019-3-23_12-22-45.png
     
  17. Phil Ham

    Phil Ham Hamster

    The Apostle Islands puck has sold out at the mint with a mintage of 16,802. It has displaced Chickasaw as the 5th rarest puck behind GRC, Hawaii, Acadia, and Denali. The AI puck will most likely lose its top five ranking considering the lack of interest in the Cumberland Island, Block Island, and Lowell pucks. Based on the lack luster sales of the Lowell puck coupled with the 2019 introduction of two territorial pucks, I'm guessing that the mint may place an internal limit of 14-15 K on some of the 2019 offerings with the Texas puck being an exception. I'm thinking that the San Antonio Missions puck may spring a short revival in the puck program.
     
    halvessearcher and SLACKACTION like this.
  18. Phil Ham

    Phil Ham Hamster

    The American Memorial Park puck went on sale in April 2019, and the mint sold 12,254 in the first week. Other pucks continue to have weak sales and the release of North Mariana Islands' offering hasn't set the puck world on fire. Voyageur is not currently available on the mint website and will most likely go to a sold out status at fewer than 17,000 sold. Other pucks available at the mint include the Cumberland Island, Block Island, and the Lowell pucks. I think that the mint has done well with the design of the latest puck. Here is some information on the puck from the mint website.

    The American Memorial Park coin is the second in 2019 and 47th overall in the puck program. American Memorial Park in the Northern Mariana Islands honors the thousands of American troops and local residents of Saipan who gave their lives during the Marianas Campaign of World War II. At the memorial, the American flag is displayed at the center of the Flag Circle and surrounded by the Navy, Marine Corps, Army, and Coast Guard flags. The Court of Honor consists of 26 granite panels inscribed with the names of 5,204 service members who died. The park’s 133 acres includes white beaches, sporting areas, picnic sites, playgrounds, and walkways. A series of wayside markers located throughout the island describe events such as the maneuvers of both American and Japanese troops, artifacts, and architectural remnants. The reverse (tails) design depicts a young woman in traditional dress at the front of the Flag Circle and Court of Honor. She is resting her hand on the plaque whose text honors the sacrifice of those who died in the Marianas Campaign of World War II. Inscriptions are "AMERICAN MEMORIAL PARK," "N. MARIANA ISLANDS," "2019," and "E PLURIBUS UNUM."

    American Memorial Park.JPG
     
  19. Phil Ham

    Phil Ham Hamster

    Voyageur is now officially sold out at 16,832. It is the seventh rarest puck but will most likely be less rare than the four pucks still on sale at the mint. The Lowell and American National Park offerings are getting very little interest from the collector's universe. They may have a tough time breaking 15,000.
     
    halvessearcher likes this.
Draft saved Draft deleted

Share This Page