Peace Dollar

Discussion in 'US Coins Forum' started by Dnna, Oct 22, 2019.

  1. Dnna

    Dnna Active Member

    Hi Everyone. The front of this Peace Dollar looks weird to me. How the hair lays on her cheek. Especially when looking through a magnifying glass. It doesn't look like random damage. Having said that, I doubt I would even be able to tell the difference. Though I must admit the back of the coin just looks like a chip. I took a third picture of what all of the Peace Dollars I have look like. Thanks for any help. New to all of this, hope the pictures are clear enough. B2606105-280C-445C-BF84-74E336D9D163.jpeg DD6074D5-9740-42EE-BC74-A0037F65C510.jpeg 31CBF7F5-CC21-458F-A9A9-F4F573B9FA89.jpeg
    Larry E and HaleiwaHI like this.
  2. Avatar

    Guest User Guest

    to hide this ad.
  3. MontCollector

    MontCollector Well-Known Member

    Welcome to CT!!!

    It is hard to to be certain from your photos. When I try to zoom in on the obverse it becomes to blurry.

    Having said that my guess would be a planchet flaw or a detached Lamination error. This looks like what is going on on the reverse as well.

    @paddyman98 what do you think?
  4. TheFinn

    TheFinn Well-Known Member

    Without clearer pictures, it could either be planchet defects or damage to the coin... or both.
    Spark1951 likes this.
  5. Dnna

    Dnna Active Member

    Thank You. I'm going to try for better pics in the morning.
  6. paddyman98

    paddyman98 Let me burst your bubble! Supporter

    Too blurry.. I'm guessing dried adhesive or post mint damage :yack:
    tibor likes this.
  7. geekpryde

    geekpryde Husband and Father Moderator

    Looks like dried glue to me. But my eyes can't tell if the substance is raised (foreign substance) or sunken, in which case its some sort of damage. If damage, it could be from the mint (lamination errors for example), or it might be Post-Mint Damage AKA PMD, such as intentional or accidental damage due to handling after it left the mint and was in the wild.

    Is there a way to hold the camera / phone exactly parallel to the coin surface? Do you have a little tripod, or some way to hold the camera so its not in your hands?
    tibor likes this.
  8. geekpryde

    geekpryde Husband and Father Moderator


    Since people are going to be throwing around acronyms like crazy, keep the below linked thread handy by bookmarking it. I suspect you will need to refer to it quite often for the first few months.

    CoinTalk Acronym Glossary

    Kentucky likes this.
  9. Mainebill

    Mainebill Wild Bill

    I think the first coin has either damage or some kind of crud stuck to it. A soak in acetone should remove any crud or glue residue. If that’s the case otherwise it’s some sort of damage after it was made
    tibor likes this.
  10. johnmilton

    johnmilton Well-Known Member

    If it above the surface of the coin, it's glue or some other kind of gunk.

    If it is INTO the coin, it's post mint damage or, less likely, planchant laminations. Those result when air or some foreign substance is trapped in the planchet which causes a chunk of metal to detactch from the piece.
    tibor likes this.
  11. Islander80-83

    Islander80-83 Well-Known Member

    Like @johnmilton suggests, is that area in question "sitting" up on the surface of the coin or is there a gouge down into the coins surface?
  12. Collecting Nut

    Collecting Nut Borderline Hoarder

    As soon as I saw the photo of the obverse I thought it was a detached lamination. Just below the area on her cheek that you're talking about there is a thin strip that goes down to her neck line. That's a very common form of a lamination error.

    I tried to enlarge the picture but it becomes blurry so I cannot determine for sure. However, upon closer inspection and noticing on the right side of her cheek in the hair is a smaller spot that looks to be the same as on her cheek.

    This makes me think it's damage but need clear photos and a close-up of that area to determine such. Please post a few clear photos of that area, one being a close-up.

    You mentioned a chip on the reverse but I'm not seeing it. A die chip would create a raised area on the coin. If you're referring to that dark spot, it looks more like a stain. Is it raised or below the coins surface? Please include a close-up of the area you're talking about.
    Islander80-83 likes this.
  13. Mountain Man

    Mountain Man Well-Known Member

    Welcome to CT. I'll wait for better pictures but my first thought was lamination error.
  14. HaleiwaHI

    HaleiwaHI Active Member

    I would be more concerned if the obv & rev damage were lined up. But it appears to have 2 issues. Obv might be delamination and the Rev might be where someone tested for PM verification.
  15. Dnna

    Dnna Active Member

    It's definitely sunken. My husband says it looks like someone took a tool to it when he was looking thru the magnifier. But he admits that's his unqualified opinion when it comes to coins. And I've been trying all day to get a better picture. I've got one I'm going post right now. All I could manage with my iPhone was to use the camera features to enlarge it. The other 2 features I used were sharpness and definition. They seemed to be the safest when the point is to identify the difference. I was afraid any other feature might enhance deceptively when what I want is clarification. I don't have a tripod but I think I know what you mean by parallel picture. I'm going to try that after I post this other one. Thanks again to everyone for looking at this for me.
  16. Dnna

    Dnna Active Member

    6463730A-E016-48E8-B47D-7F0EB00D8249.jpeg Okay. I hope this didn't make things worse. I did not want to use any feature on my phone that would give a false enhancement of what the coin actually looks like. And this picture honestly DOES look better than the coin does before I used the sharpness, and definition features. Oh, I almost forgot, I also used brightness. I was trying to do everything I could to make it easier for all of you to see. As for mentioned above. It's sunken. Also it's definitely not dirt or glue. Okay. Thanks again everyone.
  17. Dnna

    Dnna Active Member

    Yes. Thank you for that handy link. I'm very confused. But at the same time impressed. I never in a million years would have thought that this is something I would someday be talking about.
  18. Dnna

    Dnna Active Member

    It's a gouge for sure.
  19. Dnna

    Dnna Active Member

    Yes it looks like a dark spot in the photo. But it is below the surface and feels like a gouge and looks like a gouge or chip
  20. MontCollector

    MontCollector Well-Known Member

    @Dnna I have this photo from a Peace Dollar I had. Do any of the marks look similar to this?

  21. Dnna

    Dnna Active Member

    Yes I would say they do. I'm unfamiliar with the right terminology but they have a chiseled look. Parts of mine are reflective the way silver might look that's chiseled. Deliberate sort of.
Draft saved Draft deleted

Share This Page