Gtg 1854 arrows half

@ Mainebill you posted the other 2 answers. Did you forget this one?

 

Log in or Sign up to hide this ad.

Looks like a solid 45. Glad you waited for those of us that got home late from work!

 

XF 45

 

Got busy working myself this grade just baffled me. Looks like a strong 45 even a 50 to me is lightly struck in places but there's barely any wear again my pics not great. But I figured it a 50

 

I'm still at 45....who's PCGS, pfft....what do they know anyway?

 

Let's see if cac gives it a gold bean is on its way to there tomorrow. Compared to my other pcgs xf 40 arrows 1854 this is a gem. The other sucks so bad I'm embarrassed to offer it for sale

 

I like it as a 40. To me, it just doesn't have an AU "look" to it - a little too much rub, and not enough luster. I don't think that PCGS appreciates the dark toning.

 

I tend to agree on the toning. Me I'm a huge fan of gunmetal gray original silver. Is a 45 anyway. Pcgs so inconsistent lately at least they didn't detail anything this time for no reason. By the way your thd only one who got it

 

Got them both!

 

another 50 guess

 

40

 

Grades in these 2 tone blue holders are all over the place. Opportunities for savvy buyers like Mainebill.

 

Was a coin I bought raw. And sent in. Agree with the shaded blues sone real crap and some real winners there liking ngc more and more. Except when pcgs slabs some real rubbish but then I dont really wanna sell it myself

 

Wow I'm quite surprised. Hopefully the local dealers in my area will have some PCGS XF-40s like this that they want to sell for 40 money!! Not holding my breath through.

 

I sent to cac hoping for a gold bean. A real Canidate for reconsider or send to ngc

 

Wow, they were rough on that one. I was going to say 50 until you showed the grade. I'm not a huge fan of the look either, but it has far too much detail for a 40 IMHO.

 

I'm shocked. I'll be really surprised if it doesn't get at least a green bean.

 

I'd be very surprised if that got a green bean. It has an unnatural look, like its been messed with. That does not look like a coin that CAC would want.

 

In hand is a super crusty original definitely not messed with where it came from

 

pcgs tends to fault darker coloring. I don't think there is enough luster to warrant au (given that I am working from images). Might get a green bean though. Good luck!