Well you look like a coin, so there anyway ... so you did a calculation based on melt, right? ( This is not my sort of thing and I am not going to figure all that out) If so, should I understand that highly graded and very veeeeeeeeeeeerrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrryyyyyyy expensive coins would all get taxed at melt, and the tax is truly all and solely about the precious metal content and not the numismatic value? Either way, then when I go home and declare the same currency, having traded nothing during your visit - do I get a refund? Shouldn't there have to be a transaction to tax?
I'm sure you can bring in some currency tax free, about $10 000 I think, into another country. The transaction starts when you import a product like silver bullion coins.
I would say so. Currently I don't need to pay anything at the customs office. It's like "I see, US silver coins, you're good to go. Next please' if they make me pay 19% on purchasing price & shipping I would need to consider that when buying coins from dealers based in the US. So it's also bad for the sellers.
There might be a point of law here. I carry in legal US currency then carry it out. I owe tax to who for what?
It's flat out wrong that the wealthy (who can afford to pay taxes) don't have to pay any taxes if they spend a lot of money on coins, but the common man does if they buy a few coins.