Reply to Thread

Message:: [QUOTE="myownprivy, post: 3940253, member: 84588"]I think it's very important that you find out how that offer breaks down. My guess is the government issued 1 oz coins are spot or slightly above, the generic rounds are slightly below spot, and the junk silver is 5-10% below spot. If that's the case, that's all very fair. If it's not, the offers are bad. I'd sell the government 1 oz coins only for above spot. I'd accept selling the generics for slightly below spot. And I'd hang on to all the junk silver unless I really needed the money for something better or very close to spot was being offered. 279 oz of junk (not counting Peace dollars)=$4743 at spot (calculated at .715 per $1 face). A good deal. Or $4505 at 5% under, a fair deal. 166 oz of gov issued 1 oz coins (not including Libertads) should average $18ish each with silver at $17=$2988, a good deal. Or $2822 if sold at spot, a fair deal. 12 oz of generics =$204 (spot), a good deal.  Or $192 at $16 each, a fair deal. I'd expect $7935 alone on those for a good deal. A fair offer (5% under for junk, spot for gov issued, and $1 less / 6% back of spot on the generics =$7519. That's a reasonable offer but one I still wouldn't accept. This does not include the Peace Dollars or Libertads that command an obvious premium.[/QUOTE]