Message:

<p>[QUOTE=&quot;buddy16cat, post: 1462073, member: 37356&quot;]It doesn&#039;t matter what they say really because as I mentioned, I would like to see a similar coin I can buy at melt.&nbsp; There are just too many comments that make me think that their comments are unqualified anyhow.&nbsp; As I say before, it doesn&#039;t really matter what they say and don&#039;t believe them unless they can show me a similar coin with similar details being sold at melt, cleaned or not.&nbsp; Unless they have evidence to support their comments I am taking them as ego-driven, false comments.&nbsp; In another thread Doug21 argues about the grade given by NGC and I personally would take NGC&#039;s word over someone on the Internet.&nbsp;&nbsp; Unless proven otherwise I believe Books and Dougs comments are false.&nbsp; Nobody nowhere on Ebay or in a coin shop will ever sell this coin a dollar two over melt and unless they can show me evidence I simply disagree with everything they say and will no longer&nbsp; read their posts because their comments I don&#039;t believe.</p><p><br /></p><p>Since I just graduated from grad school I know the importance of supporting your statements and have yet to see any support from either Books or Doug on any comments they have made.&nbsp; Simply make a bid on a similar coin of $1 or $2 over melt on Ebay and you willl be outbid everytime.&nbsp; To me, this dictates true value since it is what someoene else will actually pay for an item rather than something written on a sheet somewhere.&nbsp; Even every guide on the Internet places this coin at significantly higher than melt even if you downgrade it.&nbsp; Since neither can support their comments, I just dismiss them as ego-driven snark.&nbsp; I hope if Books is actually writing a book he knows to support his comments or the book will be discredited and simply not sell.&nbsp; So support your comments and show me a similar coin I can buy for a dollar or two over melt.&nbsp; I don&#039;t believe that you are able to do this.&nbsp; If it is valued at a couple dollars over melt I should easily be able to find one to buy and I am not talking about some amazing deal you got from someone who knows know better. Books mentioned he would &quot;give me free advice&quot;.&nbsp; If you plan on charging for this advice I suggest you support your comments rather than just spout of anything.[/QUOTE]</p><p><br /></p>

Your name or email address:

Do you already have an account?

• No, create an account now.
• Yes, my password is:
• Forgot your password?

Stay logged in