Reply to Thread

Message:: [QUOTE="WoodyWW, post: 1200951, member: 26001"]I sent this gold $20 Saint, & $10 Indian to PCGS ("Collector's Club"). They slabbed the $20 as Genuine (94 - Altered Surface), & the $10 as Genuine (92 - Cleaned). The pics look like the coins look, meaning the color, the look, are fairly represented. The $20 Saint--looks almost identical to a PCGS MS64 $20 Saint I own. So I'm wondering if it's worth it to crack them out, & re-submit to NGC. They each might be worth what, a few hundred $$ more each if graded Unc. MS grades instead of cleaned or Altered Surface? But then there's the expense, & dues, on top of what I've already spent. And at least they're certified "Genuine". I've read a lot of posts online about the vagaries of PCGS grading......& whether or not the "Collector's Club" people are given a harder time than big submitters. Does anyone think NGC is more "fair"? Just asking, I'm a newbie here, & a newbie to submitting coins to TPG's, so any advice would  be appreciated. TIA....[/QUOTE]