Discussion in 'US Coins Forum' started by BigTee44, Jul 13, 2018.
Not my series...
Would this coin make a NGC XF40?
Log in or Sign up to hide this ad.
It has a shot.
I think it will grade VF35.
You would be cutting it close
could you verify this is the small 4?
I would grade it VF30, maybe VF35.
I hope NGC disagrees!
Yes, looks like small 4 to me.
I say VF30.
If you are a gambler.... It may, but I think it is just a wee bit shy. Solid piece though.
VF 30 imo
While I don't foresee much better than 25 or 30 (and 35 as a best-case scenario, I do agree that it's a solid piece, and appealing whatever the numerical grade ends up being.
Nice eye appeal on that one. And that always counts more to me than technical grade.
VF-35. Not an XF-40 IMO. But I like it. Nice pickup.
VF-35. Does not make EF in my opinion.
VF35, not my series either..
I also think high vF, not XF
I’m in the VF+ camp. And it is indeed the only small 4 die marriage for the year.
Just too much wear and not enough fine detail lines for XF.
I was VF 30 before reading the other posts.
Definitely not 40.
I'd call it 30 max.
Compare to the Photograde images here: https://www.pcgs.com/photograde/#/Capped10Sm/Grades
Separate names with a comma.