I agree with you. My issue is the different photos. Don't get me wrong about eBay either. I sometimes sell on there I just usually don't sell coins. EBay has changed their policies over the past year and sometimes its not worth the hassles or the risk mainly in coins. That aside, I don't think k there's ano issue of the coin itself only the condition seems a little dishonest by the seller.
Worst case scenario => it is two identical fakes for sale => run, don't walk away from this coin(s)!!