Which Would You Rather Have and Why

Discussion in 'US Coins Forum' started by Bilbo1, Mar 31, 2021.

  1. Bilbo1

    Bilbo1 Member

    Im putting together a set of 1877 Open Bud reverse Seated Liberty Half Dollars from all the Mints. I came across 2 WB-25 1877-S Transitional Reverse R-5 coins. I’d like your opinions on which you’d want in your collection. A NGC straight graded VG 8 or a raw XF with problems? 1B0B005E-D9AF-4F46-A981-6449FE3F6AC2.jpeg 48C352EB-8346-45B6-A959-7B4AFC44B88D.jpeg D8E17601-DDCC-476A-9240-C7A1AD1B900A.jpeg B3535FBB-50B5-4CE9-8C83-33C7882F9C52.jpeg
     
    Last edited: Mar 31, 2021
    capthank, wxcoin and GoldFinger1969 like this.
  2. Avatar

    Guest User Guest



    to hide this ad.
  3. potty dollar 1878

    potty dollar 1878 Well-Known Member

    First one.
     
    capthank and GH#75 like this.
  4. William F

    William F Well-Known Member

    Graded, the condition is pretty good and just seems like a better idea to go with authenticated for the old-er coins, you never know...
     
  5. Treashunt

    Treashunt The Other Frank

    definitely the problem free. And it is an NGC
    Problems will always be problems
     
    Last edited: Mar 31, 2021
    Beefer518 likes this.
  6. masterswimmer

    masterswimmer Well-Known Member

    ANACS? I see NGC.

    I'd take the straight grade, in this case. Those problems on the raw would kill me everytime I look at it.
     
  7. -jeffB

    -jeffB Greshams LEO Supporter

    That seems super-beefy for a VG grade...? Then again, I have basically zero experience grading Seated coinage.
     
    William F and Pickin and Grinin like this.
  8. Randy Abercrombie

    Randy Abercrombie Supporter! Supporter

    I will go against the grain here. I like the details on the raw coin better. Are the problems an obverse scratch or is that on the flip? Even if that scratch is on the coin, I would take the raw over the graded just from the strength of the eagle.
     
    Magnus87 likes this.
  9. Pickin and Grinin

    Pickin and Grinin Well-Known Member

    Thats what I thought. Seems closer to a F15 or maybe a VF.
    I think that it may have other problem we aren't seeing in the photo.
     
  10. dwhiz

    dwhiz Collector Supporter

    @Pickin and Grinin
    I think the area around the right breast may have keep the grade down.
    I like the first one, as far as the second one those deep scratches would keep me from buying it
     
  11. Bilbo1

    Bilbo1 Member

    Would it be worth having the NGC coin attributed? Rare Seated varieties are fun because nobody knows about them and you can usually buy them for common coin money. One of the amazing ones is if you look at PCGS CoinFacts one of the plate coins for a MS 58 1877-S is an unattributed WB 25.
     
  12. dwhiz

    dwhiz Collector Supporter

    @Bilbo1
    First are you a member of NGC, if not and you belong to the ANA you can get submitting privilege's. Other wise you would have to join NGC.
    Second I would call to make sure they would attribute that verity.
    Good Luck
     
  13. KSorbo

    KSorbo Well-Known Member

    First one for sure. I would prefer lower straight grade every time, especially in this instance as the gouges on the second one are a definite no go.
     
  14. Mr.Q

    Mr.Q Well-Known Member

    Who cares, I like it.
     
  15. Collecting Nut

    Collecting Nut Borderline Hoarder

    The problem free graded coin.
     
  16. Mountain Man

    Mountain Man Supporter! Supporter

    I guess it would depend on what you want in your collection, and of course price. The raw coin being less expensive, I am assuming.
     
  17. Bilbo1

    Bilbo1 Member

    Yes by about $10
     
  18. 1865King

    1865King Well-Known Member

    Never buy a damaged coin you have trouble selling it in the future. I wouldn't touch that raw 77 with what looks like nasty staple scratches. The VG actually my be slightly under graded. Very Nice for the Grade.
     
    dwhiz likes this.
  19. Mike Thornton

    Mike Thornton Learning something everyday.

    Problem free, graded would be my choice.
     
  20. stldanceartist

    stldanceartist Minister of Silly Walks Supporter

    For me, it would depend on cost - if I could get the raw example for $12-15*, I'd take that.

    If I could get the graded VG8 for $30, and the seller of the raw coin wanted similar money compared to the VG8, maybe I'd stick to the graded example.

    Or, if I can get good deals on both coins, maybe both. Maybe I would buy both with the expectation of putting the raw coin in an auction format to see if it would go for a lot more than I paid for it, potentially making the graded example free.

    *Yes, I've seen it happen.
     
    Bilbo1 likes this.
  21. MK Ultra

    MK Ultra Active Member

    I like the graded one. The scratch on the raw is too distracting for me.
     
    swish513 likes this.
Draft saved Draft deleted

Share This Page