#1 is #1. However, if there is something that you do not like about #1, that "something" is not going to go away after you buy it (and it could begin to bother you even more).
Thank you all for your advice, and I know many counselled to wait for a better centered coin. However, I was able to get a good discount on what I consider an already excellent price. In other words, I have decided to buy coin #1. Again, I appreciate reading everyone's opinions. CT Ancients is a great place w/o any doubt.