I like the look of the top coin a little better too, but the issue for me would be the deep mark above her eyebrow, the other on her cheeck, and the 3 marks below her eye. Also the reverse looks to have a weak strike. I'm with many of the others on looking for another coin, but if I had to choose between the two I would have to go with the bottom one simply because she did not get hit in the head with a golf club like her twin sister. Ouch! Also I think she was involved in a BB gun war and the other marks are a result of that sinister activity. On the other hand maybe shejust had a real long paper route, and got run over a couple of times.