Which Do You Like Better?

Now THAT coin I would be happy to have in my collection. The blues are lovely, and this coin now wins hands down over the old rattler in my opinion. Nice images!!!

 

Log in or Sign up to hide this ad.

Sorry didn't mean adobe, meant above !!

 

Well, I decided to keep the new one and already put the rattler on ebay. Thanks for the input!

 

I'm a fan of toned coins, so this is an easy pick for me (after seeing the newer photos). Keep the toned one.

 

What happened to "buy (or keep the coin not the holder"?

 

Want to know the honest truth? I'd sell 'em both. There's better out there to be had.

 

There's always something better out there. But can your wallet afford what's better? ??

 

My initial thought was to go with the rattler slab example...but with the second pics of the toning showing the color better, I'd keep the toned coin.

 

I chose the newer one. Threw the rattler on ebay.

 

The one in the old holder. I don't like the toning on the other one. That's just me though.
Also the one in the newer holder has some pretty MAJOR scratches on Liberty's neck.

 

I think you kept the stronger coin of the 2 based on the reverse. Both are superb examples and one can see why it was not easy to make a choice.

 

And YOU would know when a better one came by??? LOL I think you've got pretty big 1's to insult another member's coins, when we KNOW what YOU think are nice coins....unless you were shooting for counterfeit examples all along, hence your using Craig's List as your 'one stop for all your numismatic shopping needs'.

 

Send them both to cac and keep the one that cacs. At least one should cac.

 

that toning might get a corroded, details grade, if sent in again.

 

I would keep them both.

 

I would have kept the rattler and sold the other.

 

I like carrot cake.

 

I'll bet you can find all these better coins in segs, acg, gcgs, ani, nnc, nes, wcg, unc, nga, sgs, and pgs holders right?