What is this toned MS64 Morgan/toned silver eagle worth?

I picked these up in a trade, and have no clue what to ask for them. What would you say a good price would be? Purple 1881-S MS64 Morgan, and rainbow 1992 MS67 Silver Eagle. Here are videos of them:
https://www.instagram.com/p/BbkgMJHhBio/?taken-by=elizabethtown_coins
https://www.instagram.com/p/BbkfbQEhft8/?taken-by=elizabethtown_coins

 

Log in or Sign up to hide this ad.

Neither would interest me at any reasonable price. Not my thang.

 

Lol. As you know, I just bought my first silver coin, and that was because it was a one dollar coin from the 1700's! I don't really do morgans or silver eagles, though I must admit, even I like the look of the color on this Morgan. I just have no idea what price range to try and get.

 

IF I were in the market for a toned PCGS MS64 common date dollar, and I'm not, I'd think the 40-50 area is fair, based strictly on casual observation, not an exhaustive search. The ASE? No clue whatsoever. Looks like it spent some time in an album. "Not that there's anything WRONG with that." Some guys are REALLY into naturally toned ASE's, which that seems to be. I'd hesitate to even hazard a guess.

 

$100 for the Morgan. That is the most common S date.

 

I've sold several toned ASE's just like that one that came from old PCI inserts and the price is usually between $100-$150.

 

Amazing. Just stinking amazing.

 

Jeremy J says $100. I would get it right out in the mail to him.

 

Agree with Lehigh, 150 for the ASE sounds right. Could always start an auction and like a 100 and see what happens. Probably about the same for the morgan as it's not a monster

 

$100.00 for both. Smiles!

 

I sold this one in a PCI holder for $125 a few years ago.

 

I would not pay that. That is not a great coin!

 

I like both coins. An untoned 1881-S in 64 typically runs around $60 - $65. With the toning, I'd see it in the $85 - $90 range. As has been said about the Silver Eagle, it's a PCI toner and not the best example. I'd sell the Eagle for around $125.00 or so.

 

@V. Kurt Bellman, I'd take every common date PCGS MS-64 Morgan you have for $40 - $50, especially at $40.00 a pop.

 

Come to my area. It’s about typical at auction.

 

Really? Including juice? Man, I'd be at every auction buying them up.

 

Bout to post these in the for sale section, if anyone is interested

 

Many a back-country auction here has NO juice, although 10% is becoming more common. I am used to a FAAAR lower average price in my area than people talk about on here, especially on toners, which typically sell with no premium at all.

 

Man, what are 65's going for? Sorry for hijacking your thread @jwitten. I'll be PMing you soon.

 

If this is the same as before, @V. Kurt Bellman mentioned that classic gold can also go for under spot...I'm still surprised that no one has discovered these auctions or that Kurt hasn't become a full time dealer with that kind of inventory acquisition potential.