What do you think this would grade?

I’m thinking about sending this in for grading.
It would need to grade MS for me to be happy with the results.
Please share your thoughts.

 

Log in or Sign up to hide this ad.

Hmm. a little out of my League but isn't that worth 2 1/2 centesimos . That doesn't seem logical if this coin is worth less than the grading fees to have it Graded even if it graded MS-63. Very Very nice coin by the Way !

 

panama pill, nice.
I don't have one of these myself but do have a similar coin, the non-silver.

Here is the PCGS listing. Your coin would be on the low end of this population, I wouldn't suggest a submission. This is a coin that does garner interest for all I know.
https://www.pcgs.com/valueview/panama/1904-2-1-2c/2573?sn=539804&h=pop

 

I just dont see a + or anything 63 or up that would make it worth it to me

 

Very nice Panama pill. I have a few of them in lower grade. I am judging the grade on the feathers in the helmet which looks very nice. MS grade. not sure which number MS 62-63 ??? The nick on the cheek might lower the grade ???

 

I posted mine here back in June 24, 2013, sorry no close ups, my antique flip phone just makes it blurry.

 

Grade fee/value analysis, even if MS63, doesn't work for me.

Ps. I see shine, no luster? May have been cleaned at some point.