It would be hard for the numbers to look the same after this many years of getting beat and banged up in circulation.
Both are greasers. You got 2 coins that are 100 years old and now you want what? Yes, they are the same just worn a bit different.
Are you playing a game with us? In your third photo down you posted a photo of a 1920 coin on top of a 2020 coin. Of course the numeral 2 is different!!! Also, the top two photos are the same coin. Every single mark on both coins match exactly and that would not be the case after 100 years of circulation if they were different coins. If you have two different coins post them next to each other.