Log in or Sign up
Coin Talk
Home
Forums
>
Coin Forums
>
US Coins Forum
>
Walking Liberty Half Key Dates
>
Reply to Thread
Message:
<p>[QUOTE="CoinCorgi, post: 8663142, member: 88934"]I think grade plays an important part of what is key, semi-key and other. For example, numismedia prices for AU58 show that the <span style="color: #ff0000">key dates</span> include 1919D, but in lower grades (say VF20) it drops down into the <span style="color: #0080ff">semi-key</span>. I am using obviously arbitrary lines between price groups to determine key vs semi-key, so this analysis can be much more rigorous...but I ain't gonna do it for you.</p><p><br /></p><p>AU58 prices...</p><p>1916 570</p><p>1916 D 600</p><p><span style="color: #0080ff">1916 S 2070 </span></p><p>1917 168</p><p>1917 D Obv. 750</p><p>1917 D Rev. 1160</p><p><span style="color: #0080ff">1917 S Obv. 3450 </span></p><p>1917 S Rev. 760</p><p>1918 570</p><p>1918 D 1560</p><p>1918 S 600</p><p><span style="color: #0080ff">1919 1950 </span></p><p><span style="color: #ff0000">1919 D 6210 </span></p><p><span style="color: #0080ff">1919 S 4230</span></p><p>1920 450</p><p><span style="color: #0080ff">1920 D 2460 </span></p><p>1920 S 1140</p><p><span style="color: #ff0000">1921 5940 </span></p><p><span style="color: #ff0000">1921 D 8550 </span></p><p><span style="color: #ff0000">1921 S 17100 </span></p><p><span style="color: #0080ff">1923 S 3390 </span></p><p><span style="color: #0080ff">1927 S 1980 </span></p><p>1928 S 1650</p><p>1929 D 510</p><p>1929 S 540</p><p>1933 S 510</p><p>1934 62</p><p>1934 D 138</p><p>1934 S 300</p><p>1935 42</p><p>1935 D 132</p><p>1935 S 216</p><p>1936 40</p><p>1936 D 72</p><p>1936 S 100</p><p>1937 31</p><p>1937 D 126</p><p>1937 S 120</p><p>1938 66</p><p>1938 D 402</p><p>1939 34</p><p>1939 D 31</p><p>1939 S 97</p><p>1940 29</p><p>1940 S 31</p><p>1941 29</p><p>1941 D 30</p><p>1941 S 53</p><p>1942 29</p><p>1942 D 30</p><p>1942 S 31</p><p>1943 29</p><p>1943 D 34</p><p>1943 S 35</p><p>1944 29</p><p>1944 D 30</p><p>1944 S 30</p><p>1945 29</p><p>1945 D 29</p><p>1945 S 29</p><p>1946 29</p><p>1946 D 36</p><p>1946 S 29</p><p>1947 31</p><p>1947 D 34</p><p><br /></p><p>VF20 prices...</p><p>1916 180</p><p>1916 D 180</p><p><span style="color: #0080ff">1916 S 510 </span></p><p>1917 26</p><p>1917 D Obv. 180</p><p>1917 D Rev. 168</p><p><span style="color: #0080ff">1917 S Obv. 480 </span></p><p>1917 S Rev. 63</p><p>1918 71</p><p>1918 D 127</p><p>1918 S 40</p><p>1919 300</p><p><span style="color: #0080ff">1919 D 390 </span></p><p>1919 S 300</p><p>1920 45</p><p>1920 D 300</p><p>1920 S 115</p><p><span style="color: #ff0000">1921 930 </span></p><p><span style="color: #ff0000">1921 D 1380 </span></p><p><span style="color: #ff0000">1921 S 870 </span></p><p>1923 S 210</p><p>1927 S 69</p><p>1928 S 106</p><p>1929 D 41</p><p>1929 S 45</p><p>1933 S 28</p><p>1934 19</p><p>1934 D 21</p><p>1934 S 20</p><p>1935 18</p><p>1935 D 20</p><p>1935 S 20</p><p>1936 17</p><p>1936 D 17</p><p>1936 S 17</p><p>1937 17</p><p>1937 D 21</p><p>1937 S 17</p><p>1938 17</p><p>1938 D 86</p><p>1939 17</p><p>1939 D 17</p><p>1939 S 20</p><p>1940 12</p><p>1940 S 12</p><p>1941 12</p><p>1941 D 12</p><p>1941 S 12</p><p>1942 12</p><p>1942 D 12</p><p>1942 S 12</p><p>1943 12</p><p>1943 D 12</p><p>1943 S 12</p><p>1944 12</p><p>1944 D 12</p><p>1944 S 12</p><p>1945 12</p><p>1945 D 12</p><p>1945 S 12</p><p>1946 12</p><p>1946 D 14</p><p>1946 S 12</p><p>1947 12</p><p>1947 D 12[/QUOTE]</p><p><br /></p>
[QUOTE="CoinCorgi, post: 8663142, member: 88934"]I think grade plays an important part of what is key, semi-key and other. For example, numismedia prices for AU58 show that the [COLOR=#ff0000]key dates[/COLOR] include 1919D, but in lower grades (say VF20) it drops down into the [COLOR=#0080ff]semi-key[/COLOR]. I am using obviously arbitrary lines between price groups to determine key vs semi-key, so this analysis can be much more rigorous...but I ain't gonna do it for you. AU58 prices... 1916 570 1916 D 600 [COLOR=#0080ff]1916 S 2070 [/COLOR] 1917 168 1917 D Obv. 750 1917 D Rev. 1160 [COLOR=#0080ff]1917 S Obv. 3450 [/COLOR] 1917 S Rev. 760 1918 570 1918 D 1560 1918 S 600 [COLOR=#0080ff]1919 1950 [/COLOR] [COLOR=#ff0000]1919 D 6210 [/COLOR] [COLOR=#0080ff]1919 S 4230[/COLOR] 1920 450 [COLOR=#0080ff]1920 D 2460 [/COLOR] 1920 S 1140 [COLOR=#ff0000]1921 5940 1921 D 8550 1921 S 17100 [/COLOR] [COLOR=#0080ff]1923 S 3390 1927 S 1980 [/COLOR] 1928 S 1650 1929 D 510 1929 S 540 1933 S 510 1934 62 1934 D 138 1934 S 300 1935 42 1935 D 132 1935 S 216 1936 40 1936 D 72 1936 S 100 1937 31 1937 D 126 1937 S 120 1938 66 1938 D 402 1939 34 1939 D 31 1939 S 97 1940 29 1940 S 31 1941 29 1941 D 30 1941 S 53 1942 29 1942 D 30 1942 S 31 1943 29 1943 D 34 1943 S 35 1944 29 1944 D 30 1944 S 30 1945 29 1945 D 29 1945 S 29 1946 29 1946 D 36 1946 S 29 1947 31 1947 D 34 VF20 prices... 1916 180 1916 D 180 [COLOR=#0080ff]1916 S 510 [/COLOR] 1917 26 1917 D Obv. 180 1917 D Rev. 168 [COLOR=#0080ff]1917 S Obv. 480 [/COLOR] 1917 S Rev. 63 1918 71 1918 D 127 1918 S 40 1919 300 [COLOR=#0080ff]1919 D 390 [/COLOR] 1919 S 300 1920 45 1920 D 300 1920 S 115 [COLOR=#ff0000]1921 930 1921 D 1380 1921 S 870 [/COLOR] 1923 S 210 1927 S 69 1928 S 106 1929 D 41 1929 S 45 1933 S 28 1934 19 1934 D 21 1934 S 20 1935 18 1935 D 20 1935 S 20 1936 17 1936 D 17 1936 S 17 1937 17 1937 D 21 1937 S 17 1938 17 1938 D 86 1939 17 1939 D 17 1939 S 20 1940 12 1940 S 12 1941 12 1941 D 12 1941 S 12 1942 12 1942 D 12 1942 S 12 1943 12 1943 D 12 1943 S 12 1944 12 1944 D 12 1944 S 12 1945 12 1945 D 12 1945 S 12 1946 12 1946 D 14 1946 S 12 1947 12 1947 D 12[/QUOTE]
Your name or email address:
Do you already have an account?
No, create an account now.
Yes, my password is:
Forgot your password?
Stay logged in
Coin Talk
Home
Forums
>
Coin Forums
>
US Coins Forum
>
Walking Liberty Half Key Dates
>
Home
Home
Quick Links
Search Forums
Recent Activity
Recent Posts
Forums
Forums
Quick Links
Search Forums
Recent Posts
Competitions
Competitions
Quick Links
Competition Index
Rules, Terms & Conditions
Gallery
Gallery
Quick Links
Search Media
New Media
Showcase
Showcase
Quick Links
Search Items
Most Active Members
New Items
Directory
Directory
Quick Links
Directory Home
New Listings
Members
Members
Quick Links
Notable Members
Current Visitors
Recent Activity
New Profile Posts
Sponsors
Menu
Search
Search titles only
Posted by Member:
Separate names with a comma.
Newer Than:
Search this thread only
Search this forum only
Display results as threads
Useful Searches
Recent Posts
More...