If both of you are really serious about this, (Paul I know you are) then I will have no problem going through with this. I shall contact someone with a PCGS membership who can send the coin in for me, I will pay the fees for getting it graded, and if the coin upgrades Doug will pay me, if not Paul will. If I have the green light from you Doug, then let's do this thing!
Ooooooh, I gotta bookmark this page for now. I gotta be on Pauls side. I just don't see it getting an upgrade. IMO, it is certified correctly and the rules are still the same. This is getting interesting. When is it going back T$?
One of those situations where I knew what I was typing, but it didn't come out how I had intended. I for one think that you will win this bet, and Doug will end up paying. I grade the thing 63, and it is accurately graded. I have a strong feeling PCGS will see and feel the same.
Alright, when I get the amount of funds I need to pay for this thing myself, I will do so and keep you all updated.