The Official CoinTalk Grading Experiment 26

I went with 65. Strike is nice, minimal marks. I couldnt tell if the neck is pitting or hits. Either way I think the CC gives it a little extra wiggle room so 65.

 

Log in or Sign up to hide this ad.

I was between 64 and 65....to me it just misses a 65 (upper tier 64), so I voted 64...seeing it in a 65 holder would not surprise me though

 

Solid 65 for a 78-cc. Too much little chatter for higher no major marks to drop it to 64. If it was an s mint it’d be a nice 64

 

I chose MS64 just for the bag marks. A few less and it would be a 65. Nice luster and detail.

 

Ms65

 

I'm guessing 66, massive amounts of luster and I think the cheek marks are trivial.

 

Voted MS 65.Would go higher except for the marks on the neck.

 

With 35 guesses, the CT average is 64.86. Not bad, but a little low - PCGS and CAC gave this a 65. There is a surprisingly tight spread on the guesses this time - at most, you were one point off!

As usual, Messy nails the analysis. There are just a few too many marks for a 66, but I would expect a 64 to either have a couple of decent sized marks, or have more marks in the fields.