The Monster Toned Coin Game Thread

I revised my answer, after seeing the video. It is a solid 5.0. I love the colors. Nice high level toner.

 

Log in or Sign up to hide this ad.

I'll share a little more info regarding the coin after more people guess. It's not a ton but still an interesting tidbit.

 

I would be happy to own it. The lower sub-gem grade is because of muted luster. Had it been more lustrous, it could have been a near pastel monster.

 

I agree-a combination of luster and some hits in focal areas (like below the corner of the eye)

 

4.9

 

5.0

 

@Morgandude11 this is a Morgan I can stand behind. 5.5 for me on that beauty.

 

I like it, also.

 

Gorgeous Morgan, both obverse and reverse. Lovely, and a 5.3 from me.

 

I am going to post another Morgan. I found the archives of ones I owned and posted back in 2011 and 2012 on Cointalk. We can handle two at once. This is an 1898 NGC MS 64

 

The date makes it more interesting. I compared it to the coin from round 1, which I rated at 4. This one reminds me a bit of that one but falls slightly short of it.
My score is a 3.6

 

Nice crescent toning on a golden coin.
I m at 4.2

 

3.8

 

3.8

 

I’m at a 3.5 on that one.

 

Let's run both Morgans until tomorrow.
These are the two currently in play:

https://www.cointalk.com/threads/the-monster-toned-coin-game-thread.363437/page-91#post-5579868

https://www.cointalk.com/threads/the-monster-toned-coin-game-thread.363437/page-92#post-5645058

@Lehigh96 @jtlee321 @kSigSteve and others still time to get your scores in

....and I still have to add the tidbit about my Morgan

 

For some reason, this site keeps not notifying me of posts in my watched threads.

The 1884-O I would call a 4.2

The 1898 a 4.7

 

I'm at 3.5 on both

 

4.0
3.5

 

For my Morgan, I'm at 4.5.

The tidbit is that it used to be in an NGC holder but without a star. I'm not sure why as this one looks star worthy. Someone crossed it to PCGS and I bought it in the PCGS holder. Despite not having a star, this one was bid up aggressively at auction. I was luckily able to buy it for less in the PCGS holder (not something you often see).