The Monster Toned Coin Game Thread

3.5 on the Kroner.

 

Log in or Sign up to hide this ad.

Ok, another Jefferson Nickel. 1971s. PCGS PR 68

 

I feel like I am rewarding this coin both for its relatively young age and the fact that you just don't see green on modern toned proof Jefferson Nickels.

5.25

 

Green is rare on proof Jeffs. The 70s ones sometimes get it from mint packaging, just like the 60-68 ones.

 

5.0

 

Oh my I’m at a 5 with that Jefferson. It should be in a skittles commercial.

 

Pretty 5.0

 

I'm at at 4.9

The Norwegian coin is still in play too since there have not been many replies on it yet.

 

3.0 on the 100Kr. Lack of other colors keeps it low IMO
5.5 on the 71S Proof Nickel I like multi colored toning on proof coins, especially when it's on both sides.

 

The 1971s Jefferson is beautiful in hand. My son gave it to me last Christmas. I agree with a consensus in the 5s. So, I will rate it as 5.3. Very tough to get a monster on a Jefferson nickel, for numerous reasons, especially a proof, as opposed to business strike.

 

I'd put the Jeff at 5.4, but those pics look like majorly juice-o-matic!

 

Tired of horsey’s provocation. Ignore list again. “ High Ho, Silver.”

 

5.3 on the Jeff.

 

Okay, bump this thread. 1968s JFKHalf. PCGS PR 68

 

I have a question for you, how do you get your coins toning imaged so well???

 

4.2 for me. If not for the toning on his neck I would have been at 4.5.

 

I am going a little lower on this one. Kennedy's tone up pretty good in mint state, and this one while nice probably has a very dark appearance in hand unless it is flooded with light on the surfaces.

3.5

 

I'll update the other rounds at a later point.

I'm going with a 4.0....the spot on the neck hurts a little

@Lehigh96 this is a proof (which makes your point stronger)