The Monster Toned Coin Game Thread

A real beauty. Obverse toning is a magnificent rainbow. Just a touch shy of a 5. I would say 4.8, so that makes it a high 4.

 

Log in or Sign up to hide this ad.

Beautiful coin. It’s a 4 for me. I think this coin at 65+ and maybe PL would push it to a 5.

 

The double crescent is kind of neat, but I'm not getting enough "wow" effect to go higher than a 4.

 

The quality of toning and surface preservation says 4, but the coolness factor of the double crescent brings it to a 5 for me.

 

I'm in the "4" camp.

 

It kind of straddles the fence between a 4 and 5.

 

Yes we can do non-Morgans.
@physics-fan3.14 can post next and then you can post @Morgandude11
@brg5658 can join in too.

 

There is a fun story related to that.
The first picture is GC.
I've owned the coin twice now. The first time I sold it to one of those guys that insists on TruViews. He ended up sending it back to PCGS for a TruView to be taken. It's sold at least once more after that until I bought it again recently.

 

Summary
Rd. 1: 1883-O Morgan NGC MS63* [Obv]...CT -> 3.6 (Mid) vs You -> 4 (Mid-High)
Rd. 2: 1880 Morgan PCGS MS62 [Obv]...CT -> 2.7 (Low-Mid) vs You -> 3 (Mid)
Rd. 3: 1881-S Morgan PCGS MS65 [Rev]...CT -> 3 (Mid) vs You -> 3 (Mid)
Rd. 4: 1880-S Morgan PCGS MS65 [Obv]...CT -> 4.6 (Mid-High) vs You -> 5 (High)
Rd. 5: 1880-S Morgan NGC MS66* [Obv]...CT -> 3.2 (Mid) vs You -> 3 (Mid)
Rd. 6: 1880-S Morgan PCGS MS?? [Rev]...CT -> 3.5 (Mid) vs You -> 3 (Mid)
Rd. 7: 1887 Morgan PCGS MS64 [Obv]...CT-> 4.2 (Mid-High) vs You-> 4 (Mid-High)

 

@physics-fan3.14 you're up
followed by @Morgandude11
and then @brg5658
for a trifecta of non-Morgans

 

That 1939-D Lincoln Cent is a solid 4 for me. It's pushing my threshold of personal preferences and approaching a 5.

Superb coin Jason!

 

Nice coin, with beautiful toning. 4 but a high 4.

 

I'm also at 4 ...lovely example!

 

To me, that Lincoln is a solid 5, but I might change my mind if I saw a slab photo.

 

gotta pick a 3 Just a guess

 

I'll say 4.
Though I don't have much idea about toned copper.

 

Neat thread @ddddd!

Jason, I'm at a 5 on that one.

 

Thanks everyone, I agree that this is a 5.

 

Okay, next up. Question is, do you like Ike? MS 63. Was part of the Golden Nugget Horde, and somebody crossed it to PCGS from ICG, where all the others were slabbed, as Casino tokens for Whales: