Log in or Sign up
Coin Talk
Home
Forums
>
Coin Forums
>
Ancient Coins
>
The Missing Link- Coin Development in Southeast Asia
>
Reply to Thread
Message:
<p>[QUOTE="Ancientnoob, post: 2745072, member: 44140"]Recently, I posted a coin of Ancient Burma (Myanmar), for fun as a "Mystery Coin of the Day, of which [USER=56859]@TIF[/USER] was able to deduce its origin. She was able to do this (even though being generally unfamiliar with these coins) by realizing their was a huge Conch shell on the obverse and the Srivatsa reverse, both of which are considered auspicious symbols in both Hinduism and Buddhism. She also deduced that the coin was from Burma based on similar coin fabric as a coin of the region I had posted many moons ago. For this I give her mad props. The reason for the mad props is that this is a very important skill when determining the origin of coins of Southeast Asia. As archaeological study of the various civilizations is in its infancy and the coins them selves are inherently rare, this is how numismatic experts go about about cataloging these coins. They take an educated guess.</p><p><br /></p><p>Michael Mitchiner did the same when he attributed this coin to the Davaravati kingdom. The Dvaravati was both a kingdom and a cultural / Ethnic identity of a people, spanning a huge geographical area in Burma,Thailand and Cambodia. The differentiation between them and the Mon culture is rather blurred and often you see a reference like "The Mon Kingdom of Dvaravati. Likely referring to the Mon culture who established a kingdom in Thailand in the mid 5th century AD. (now hold that thought)</p><p><br /></p><p>For a little back ground: The Mon culture is thought to have originated in Burma, sometime during the Pyu (pronounced Pew) Period. The Pyu are credited being the first culture to settle Burma of which records exist sometime around BC 200. Historically the Mon were located in Lower Burma and the Pyu in the central region.</p><p><br /></p><p>The Pyu City States as well the Mon Culture of Thaton and Pegu coexisted for nearly 1000 years as a trade hub between India and China. There are several accounts in ancient Chinese history of cities of great wealth and power minting coins of silver. It is also mentioned as being a destination of Arab traders in the 8th century. Their contribution to art and architecture in the region continued long after they were gone and forgotten. Mon and Pyu coinage came to an abrupt end when their cities were overrun and destroyed by the Chinese of Nanzhao in AD 832. Early Rising Sun coinage would come to end with the collapse of Funan (another culture and post for a different day) in Thailand around AD 550.</p><p><br /></p><p><br /></p><p>In Burma, Pagan would rise and preserved much of the art and architectural style. They would continue with an advanced culture, trade and commerce would flourish for centuries yet metal was never again to be struck into coin as it had been in the good ol' days. The Mon Kingdom of Dvaravati would continue to produce conch style coinage up to about AD 1050. Local lead coinage would replace silver in Cambodia under the Khmer ( AD 802 -1431.) Otherwise coinage would not return to the region until the arrival of Europeans in the 16th and 17th centuries.</p><p><br /></p><p>Ok, I know I have thrown a lot of information at you and if you are still reading I commend you. I titled this thread "The Missing Link", why you ask? Well... this coin is interesting in that it combines the the conch obverse of the Mon coins of Pegu with the reverse linear srivatsa of the Beikthano, Pyu Rising Sun type. (Also produced by Funan in Thailand.) The Rising Sun types are still considered "unattributed". WOW! The linkage does not seem to be coincidental or superficial. It even extends to the ancillary symbols in the reverse left and right fields!</p><p><br /></p><p>Determining actual mints and dates for the coinage of Southeast Asia is exceptionally difficult as nearly all the silver coinage ever produced in the region has really large distribution, extending from Eastern Bengal to the coast of Vietnam. The greatest concentration of this coin type comes from Syriam a Mon city in Burma.</p><p><br /></p><p>The first foreign account of Syriam was the Arab Geographer ibn Khordadbeh, in AD 850. At this time Syriam was in decline and eventually fell to Pagan in AD 1056. In turn Pagan collapsed in AD 1287 due to repeated Mongol invasions, and after he Mon would again regain their Independence.</p><p><br /></p><p>By the 1580's the harbor of Syriam had silted up and was still visited by European traders when Pegu fell to the Portuguese in 1599 and the rest is....well Modern History.</p><p><br /></p><p>Oh yea, and the coin got a bath in a sodium bicarbonate solution...</p><p><br /></p><p>Burma, Syriam</p><p>Anonymous Civic Coinage (AD 550-675)</p><p>AR Full Unit (96 Ratti)</p><p>28 mm x 8.14 grams</p><p>Obverse: Conventionalized Conch Shell within solid bead at base with 2 concentric lines on the body, all within a line and bead border.</p><p>Reverse: Simplified Linear Srivatsa. Swastika to right, Bhadrapitha to left. and Crescent moon in the upper left. Sun in the upper right.</p><p>Ref: Wicks Class F. pg.113</p><p>Note: Alternate reported find spots; U Thong, Thailand, Sri Ksetra, Burma</p><p>Prov: Private Collection, Tochigi, Japan</p><p>[ATTACH=full]627388[/ATTACH]</p><p><img src="https://s27.postimg.org/vvn5m5p8z/BML.jpg" class="bbCodeImage wysiwygImage" alt="" unselectable="on" />[/QUOTE]</p><p><br /></p>
[QUOTE="Ancientnoob, post: 2745072, member: 44140"]Recently, I posted a coin of Ancient Burma (Myanmar), for fun as a "Mystery Coin of the Day, of which [USER=56859]@TIF[/USER] was able to deduce its origin. She was able to do this (even though being generally unfamiliar with these coins) by realizing their was a huge Conch shell on the obverse and the Srivatsa reverse, both of which are considered auspicious symbols in both Hinduism and Buddhism. She also deduced that the coin was from Burma based on similar coin fabric as a coin of the region I had posted many moons ago. For this I give her mad props. The reason for the mad props is that this is a very important skill when determining the origin of coins of Southeast Asia. As archaeological study of the various civilizations is in its infancy and the coins them selves are inherently rare, this is how numismatic experts go about about cataloging these coins. They take an educated guess. Michael Mitchiner did the same when he attributed this coin to the Davaravati kingdom. The Dvaravati was both a kingdom and a cultural / Ethnic identity of a people, spanning a huge geographical area in Burma,Thailand and Cambodia. The differentiation between them and the Mon culture is rather blurred and often you see a reference like "The Mon Kingdom of Dvaravati. Likely referring to the Mon culture who established a kingdom in Thailand in the mid 5th century AD. (now hold that thought) For a little back ground: The Mon culture is thought to have originated in Burma, sometime during the Pyu (pronounced Pew) Period. The Pyu are credited being the first culture to settle Burma of which records exist sometime around BC 200. Historically the Mon were located in Lower Burma and the Pyu in the central region. The Pyu City States as well the Mon Culture of Thaton and Pegu coexisted for nearly 1000 years as a trade hub between India and China. There are several accounts in ancient Chinese history of cities of great wealth and power minting coins of silver. It is also mentioned as being a destination of Arab traders in the 8th century. Their contribution to art and architecture in the region continued long after they were gone and forgotten. Mon and Pyu coinage came to an abrupt end when their cities were overrun and destroyed by the Chinese of Nanzhao in AD 832. Early Rising Sun coinage would come to end with the collapse of Funan (another culture and post for a different day) in Thailand around AD 550. In Burma, Pagan would rise and preserved much of the art and architectural style. They would continue with an advanced culture, trade and commerce would flourish for centuries yet metal was never again to be struck into coin as it had been in the good ol' days. The Mon Kingdom of Dvaravati would continue to produce conch style coinage up to about AD 1050. Local lead coinage would replace silver in Cambodia under the Khmer ( AD 802 -1431.) Otherwise coinage would not return to the region until the arrival of Europeans in the 16th and 17th centuries. Ok, I know I have thrown a lot of information at you and if you are still reading I commend you. I titled this thread "The Missing Link", why you ask? Well... this coin is interesting in that it combines the the conch obverse of the Mon coins of Pegu with the reverse linear srivatsa of the Beikthano, Pyu Rising Sun type. (Also produced by Funan in Thailand.) The Rising Sun types are still considered "unattributed". WOW! The linkage does not seem to be coincidental or superficial. It even extends to the ancillary symbols in the reverse left and right fields! Determining actual mints and dates for the coinage of Southeast Asia is exceptionally difficult as nearly all the silver coinage ever produced in the region has really large distribution, extending from Eastern Bengal to the coast of Vietnam. The greatest concentration of this coin type comes from Syriam a Mon city in Burma. The first foreign account of Syriam was the Arab Geographer ibn Khordadbeh, in AD 850. At this time Syriam was in decline and eventually fell to Pagan in AD 1056. In turn Pagan collapsed in AD 1287 due to repeated Mongol invasions, and after he Mon would again regain their Independence. By the 1580's the harbor of Syriam had silted up and was still visited by European traders when Pegu fell to the Portuguese in 1599 and the rest is....well Modern History. Oh yea, and the coin got a bath in a sodium bicarbonate solution... Burma, Syriam Anonymous Civic Coinage (AD 550-675) AR Full Unit (96 Ratti) 28 mm x 8.14 grams Obverse: Conventionalized Conch Shell within solid bead at base with 2 concentric lines on the body, all within a line and bead border. Reverse: Simplified Linear Srivatsa. Swastika to right, Bhadrapitha to left. and Crescent moon in the upper left. Sun in the upper right. Ref: Wicks Class F. pg.113 Note: Alternate reported find spots; U Thong, Thailand, Sri Ksetra, Burma Prov: Private Collection, Tochigi, Japan [ATTACH=full]627388[/ATTACH] [IMG]https://s27.postimg.org/vvn5m5p8z/BML.jpg[/IMG][/QUOTE]
Your name or email address:
Do you already have an account?
No, create an account now.
Yes, my password is:
Forgot your password?
Stay logged in
Coin Talk
Home
Forums
>
Coin Forums
>
Ancient Coins
>
The Missing Link- Coin Development in Southeast Asia
>
Home
Home
Quick Links
Search Forums
Recent Activity
Recent Posts
Forums
Forums
Quick Links
Search Forums
Recent Posts
Competitions
Competitions
Quick Links
Competition Index
Rules, Terms & Conditions
Gallery
Gallery
Quick Links
Search Media
New Media
Showcase
Showcase
Quick Links
Search Items
Most Active Members
New Items
Directory
Directory
Quick Links
Directory Home
New Listings
Members
Members
Quick Links
Notable Members
Current Visitors
Recent Activity
New Profile Posts
Sponsors
Menu
Search
Search titles only
Posted by Member:
Separate names with a comma.
Newer Than:
Search this thread only
Search this forum only
Display results as threads
Useful Searches
Recent Posts
More...