Log in or Sign up
Coin Talk
Home
Forums
>
Coin Forums
>
US Coins Forum
>
Should coins with too many chops be discounted?
>
Reply to Thread
Message:
<p>[QUOTE="goldrealmoney79, post: 5236692, member: 111622"]I know trade dollars have chop marks, and that there is crowd that collects them and I understand the appeal. I myself like a coin with thoughtfully placed chop. However the problem I have is there are some coins with so many chops that details of the coin are obscured severely. If you get too many on one side then the other side gets damaged from all metal movement as well. These coins with too many chops have so many details and beauty lost that they should be sold at a severe discount. Am i wrong to think so? Do you think there should be a premium for too many chops? </p><p>For example this one below is being marketed as monster chop marks, but I dont see the appeal to all the damage. </p><p><br /></p><p><a href="https://rover.ebay.com/rover/1/711-53200-19255-0/1?mpre=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.ebay.com%2Fitm%2F1874-CC-T-1-Chop-Mark-Trade-Dollar-PCGS-XF-45-Extra-Fine-to-AU-Monster-Chop-M%2F373168684105%3Fhash%3Ditem56e2963c49%26_trkparms%3Dispr%253D1%26amdata%3Denc%253AAQAFAAADULVvn2LJf8hh21AVPvn2u0WBOsk4qB9DQ3IoWT9I1xFVdHNcQcBJ%25252BKNR4CNbamTjb9sMjhh6JhUWei%25252F6ARxfaGj7dgpuJI0xh4cQjcWcT%25252BkMESRIwqNResva81vuHMh7q%25252Fay0UQk%25252BhIa%25252FUL1nOoh%25252BPRh3cXtQm4FY%25252BKDaVt1aU0z6ezAigiqdwtaPCWcFLeEkEx2SI3l15VWLFFu0EfS2x%25252FDGGBnKUGen4RIADawVoqpH1e7S7D%25252Bk6KZIEPX38SWt5xtsfcn5jpo%25252F9XSDhKj9Nj%25252FMwIgnfnf8l5PEPmHzxoGJUiOx8C0HcmIS5pBt0zz%25252BGO2Sex36ORYJNpev4DFzAyWFnTrbzMJJ2i%25252BXGGFloxxG%25252FyH8P%25252BqUF%25252BNujvf1rkibidbD2NTpdwjtr6H7R1zVnSEIzw70wwCtca7ExPMWMZtmy5Fr3l%25252Fh4v63sde6WVlfMP%25252B3t3BlVXHF4iL79HYSqSZG1znDrs%25252FcHWAKoX4JvN%25252FMzUtOdnfPE4MkOiW8pIBrgToKX8ZwIlXA4Qb1StI92xLKINxRv%25252FaVA17wVWfPNibBQZO%25252FigW3mokjs2nBCZAdbJ3STsyaQqXk7sEsbLJjeSVJpFh%25252FhIwQCN6pLK1HlzNDMYlVn4uJoT%25252B%25252FyCVjlQ4cC9pnjbhyfL4McEci1RTLwXovWu%25252FsPSGHUUhq2F7cy626JdkIieqvvG6k64WqMub4VeiG1%25252BmLwKM6myS6uZDehPP4QDQDgcBrIiujRAB%25252FS368DqRxjT2tQrJe3OorVfPV2szK4SUJUfHQw1sN2OhwFGF6%25252Fnz59N9ceL3ptl8%25252B9MwH7o3LrikoW%25252F%25252FI6xcDMjrNPMuvfMdXrC49cUua7HtcGxYO4HwhuveVulKB0ZDo8ffMSROUWJpG34jkPsEqqnQD6cDhPyAtNf9WPM8nxE2w9hIorhQ6aIpIBAvZzBHCmE%25252B06W55oUQETeidaJ1rSPGYL2HTaNfvn3CCdj4yB6CsybSpDlKTdID3hshDEtl9qZ9IB%25252BYdnABI47SRbBdwf1LUz%25252BBVldpHCyZc%25252FwEiM0W1DiyOaSOjG%25252BZkneuAtTpIVahtKjOlkC2CLhbndTlVecrKQTWAyBF1AJlysbJnutlQ4MpntIOd9pRpI61igpg7kVb%257Ccksum%253A37316868410533f1cb81d03442d7a8c10b173632e4e5%257Campid%253APL_CLK&campid=5338688952&toolid=10001&customid=" target="_blank" class="externalLink ProxyLink" data-proxy-href="https://rover.ebay.com/rover/1/711-53200-19255-0/1?mpre=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.ebay.com%2Fitm%2F1874-CC-T-1-Chop-Mark-Trade-Dollar-PCGS-XF-45-Extra-Fine-to-AU-Monster-Chop-M%2F373168684105%3Fhash%3Ditem56e2963c49%26_trkparms%3Dispr%253D1%26amdata%3Denc%253AAQAFAAADULVvn2LJf8hh21AVPvn2u0WBOsk4qB9DQ3IoWT9I1xFVdHNcQcBJ%25252BKNR4CNbamTjb9sMjhh6JhUWei%25252F6ARxfaGj7dgpuJI0xh4cQjcWcT%25252BkMESRIwqNResva81vuHMh7q%25252Fay0UQk%25252BhIa%25252FUL1nOoh%25252BPRh3cXtQm4FY%25252BKDaVt1aU0z6ezAigiqdwtaPCWcFLeEkEx2SI3l15VWLFFu0EfS2x%25252FDGGBnKUGen4RIADawVoqpH1e7S7D%25252Bk6KZIEPX38SWt5xtsfcn5jpo%25252F9XSDhKj9Nj%25252FMwIgnfnf8l5PEPmHzxoGJUiOx8C0HcmIS5pBt0zz%25252BGO2Sex36ORYJNpev4DFzAyWFnTrbzMJJ2i%25252BXGGFloxxG%25252FyH8P%25252BqUF%25252BNujvf1rkibidbD2NTpdwjtr6H7R1zVnSEIzw70wwCtca7ExPMWMZtmy5Fr3l%25252Fh4v63sde6WVlfMP%25252B3t3BlVXHF4iL79HYSqSZG1znDrs%25252FcHWAKoX4JvN%25252FMzUtOdnfPE4MkOiW8pIBrgToKX8ZwIlXA4Qb1StI92xLKINxRv%25252FaVA17wVWfPNibBQZO%25252FigW3mokjs2nBCZAdbJ3STsyaQqXk7sEsbLJjeSVJpFh%25252FhIwQCN6pLK1HlzNDMYlVn4uJoT%25252B%25252FyCVjlQ4cC9pnjbhyfL4McEci1RTLwXovWu%25252FsPSGHUUhq2F7cy626JdkIieqvvG6k64WqMub4VeiG1%25252BmLwKM6myS6uZDehPP4QDQDgcBrIiujRAB%25252FS368DqRxjT2tQrJe3OorVfPV2szK4SUJUfHQw1sN2OhwFGF6%25252Fnz59N9ceL3ptl8%25252B9MwH7o3LrikoW%25252F%25252FI6xcDMjrNPMuvfMdXrC49cUua7HtcGxYO4HwhuveVulKB0ZDo8ffMSROUWJpG34jkPsEqqnQD6cDhPyAtNf9WPM8nxE2w9hIorhQ6aIpIBAvZzBHCmE%25252B06W55oUQETeidaJ1rSPGYL2HTaNfvn3CCdj4yB6CsybSpDlKTdID3hshDEtl9qZ9IB%25252BYdnABI47SRbBdwf1LUz%25252BBVldpHCyZc%25252FwEiM0W1DiyOaSOjG%25252BZkneuAtTpIVahtKjOlkC2CLhbndTlVecrKQTWAyBF1AJlysbJnutlQ4MpntIOd9pRpI61igpg7kVb%257Ccksum%253A37316868410533f1cb81d03442d7a8c10b173632e4e5%257Campid%253APL_CLK&campid=5338688952&toolid=10001&customid=" rel="nofollow">https://www.ebay.com/itm/1874-CC-T-1-Chop-Mark-Trade-Dollar-PCGS-XF-45-Extra-Fine-to-AU-Monster-Chop-M/</a>[/QUOTE]</p><p><br /></p>
[QUOTE="goldrealmoney79, post: 5236692, member: 111622"]I know trade dollars have chop marks, and that there is crowd that collects them and I understand the appeal. I myself like a coin with thoughtfully placed chop. However the problem I have is there are some coins with so many chops that details of the coin are obscured severely. If you get too many on one side then the other side gets damaged from all metal movement as well. These coins with too many chops have so many details and beauty lost that they should be sold at a severe discount. Am i wrong to think so? Do you think there should be a premium for too many chops? For example this one below is being marketed as monster chop marks, but I dont see the appeal to all the damage. [URL='https://rover.ebay.com/rover/1/711-53200-19255-0/1?mpre=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.ebay.com%2Fitm%2F1874-CC-T-1-Chop-Mark-Trade-Dollar-PCGS-XF-45-Extra-Fine-to-AU-Monster-Chop-M%2F373168684105%3Fhash%3Ditem56e2963c49%26_trkparms%3Dispr%253D1%26amdata%3Denc%253AAQAFAAADULVvn2LJf8hh21AVPvn2u0WBOsk4qB9DQ3IoWT9I1xFVdHNcQcBJ%25252BKNR4CNbamTjb9sMjhh6JhUWei%25252F6ARxfaGj7dgpuJI0xh4cQjcWcT%25252BkMESRIwqNResva81vuHMh7q%25252Fay0UQk%25252BhIa%25252FUL1nOoh%25252BPRh3cXtQm4FY%25252BKDaVt1aU0z6ezAigiqdwtaPCWcFLeEkEx2SI3l15VWLFFu0EfS2x%25252FDGGBnKUGen4RIADawVoqpH1e7S7D%25252Bk6KZIEPX38SWt5xtsfcn5jpo%25252F9XSDhKj9Nj%25252FMwIgnfnf8l5PEPmHzxoGJUiOx8C0HcmIS5pBt0zz%25252BGO2Sex36ORYJNpev4DFzAyWFnTrbzMJJ2i%25252BXGGFloxxG%25252FyH8P%25252BqUF%25252BNujvf1rkibidbD2NTpdwjtr6H7R1zVnSEIzw70wwCtca7ExPMWMZtmy5Fr3l%25252Fh4v63sde6WVlfMP%25252B3t3BlVXHF4iL79HYSqSZG1znDrs%25252FcHWAKoX4JvN%25252FMzUtOdnfPE4MkOiW8pIBrgToKX8ZwIlXA4Qb1StI92xLKINxRv%25252FaVA17wVWfPNibBQZO%25252FigW3mokjs2nBCZAdbJ3STsyaQqXk7sEsbLJjeSVJpFh%25252FhIwQCN6pLK1HlzNDMYlVn4uJoT%25252B%25252FyCVjlQ4cC9pnjbhyfL4McEci1RTLwXovWu%25252FsPSGHUUhq2F7cy626JdkIieqvvG6k64WqMub4VeiG1%25252BmLwKM6myS6uZDehPP4QDQDgcBrIiujRAB%25252FS368DqRxjT2tQrJe3OorVfPV2szK4SUJUfHQw1sN2OhwFGF6%25252Fnz59N9ceL3ptl8%25252B9MwH7o3LrikoW%25252F%25252FI6xcDMjrNPMuvfMdXrC49cUua7HtcGxYO4HwhuveVulKB0ZDo8ffMSROUWJpG34jkPsEqqnQD6cDhPyAtNf9WPM8nxE2w9hIorhQ6aIpIBAvZzBHCmE%25252B06W55oUQETeidaJ1rSPGYL2HTaNfvn3CCdj4yB6CsybSpDlKTdID3hshDEtl9qZ9IB%25252BYdnABI47SRbBdwf1LUz%25252BBVldpHCyZc%25252FwEiM0W1DiyOaSOjG%25252BZkneuAtTpIVahtKjOlkC2CLhbndTlVecrKQTWAyBF1AJlysbJnutlQ4MpntIOd9pRpI61igpg7kVb%257Ccksum%253A37316868410533f1cb81d03442d7a8c10b173632e4e5%257Campid%253APL_CLK&campid=5338688952&toolid=10001&customid=']https://www.ebay.com/itm/1874-CC-T-1-Chop-Mark-Trade-Dollar-PCGS-XF-45-Extra-Fine-to-AU-Monster-Chop-M/[/URL][/QUOTE]
Your name or email address:
Do you already have an account?
No, create an account now.
Yes, my password is:
Forgot your password?
Stay logged in
Coin Talk
Home
Forums
>
Coin Forums
>
US Coins Forum
>
Should coins with too many chops be discounted?
>
Home
Home
Quick Links
Search Forums
Recent Activity
Recent Posts
Forums
Forums
Quick Links
Search Forums
Recent Posts
Competitions
Competitions
Quick Links
Competition Index
Rules, Terms & Conditions
Gallery
Gallery
Quick Links
Search Media
New Media
Showcase
Showcase
Quick Links
Search Items
Most Active Members
New Items
Directory
Directory
Quick Links
Directory Home
New Listings
Members
Members
Quick Links
Notable Members
Current Visitors
Recent Activity
New Profile Posts
Sponsors
Menu
Search
Search titles only
Posted by Member:
Separate names with a comma.
Newer Than:
Search this thread only
Search this forum only
Display results as threads
Useful Searches
Recent Posts
More...