Looking for some advice, I have extras of the ATB 5oz bullion pucks that I'm ready to unload. I have every coin from 2010-2014, 25 in total. Went to the local shop and they were offering .50 cents under spot on generics. It looks like flea bay has them going for higher depending on the coin. I know there are some weird one off coins like the Hawaii puck and others. What do you think is the best way to unload them? Sell them in a set for each year on flea bay or individually? Or just all at once?
Compare to the average for a year set and the individuals and see whats higher, factor in shipping and whatever brings more. The standout ones of the highest value will probably do best as individuals. eBay almost certainly will be your best bet though, most shops seem to just want to buy them as silver.
Thanks for the input on selling on here! Being a newbie to posting on Cointalk but a long term lurker I wasn't sure how newbie sellers were treated on here. I guess the days of paypal make it much easier to trust folks online. I'll look into the sale side and instructions.
If you're not squeamish about Craigslist I'd suggest that route, I've sold and bartered a few on there and you don't pay the outrageous fleabay and paypal fees.
I'd offer them here, definitely. I might check out your local Facebook yard sale group, too. Unlike Craigslist, there is some measure of personal accountability there (although you'll still get your fair share of nut jobs, lowballers, and rude people.)
All right I'll do my obligatory 10 posts then I will post on the For Sale board. I think I am going to see if I can sell them in a year (5 coin) bundle. Thanks for the help!
I would sell them individually here on CT. People usually do not want entire years but only the ones they missed.
And will we ever see you again after that? After all, 10 posts is still cheaper than "flea bay" for you.
