Rim cud or PMD?

I really can't tell. Took a flyer on it. 9 o'clock on the reverse. ??

 

Log in or Sign up to hide this ad.

Maybe this is better. Guess not. It won't enlarge any better.

 

PMD, it's just a rim bump.

 

More of a "rim ding". LOL.

 

Like this one? lol........... but seriously, I'm not sure. The one depicted isn't PMD. Win some, lose some.

 

Yeah, go figure. Dammmmmmmmmmmit! Thanks Sal.

 

This one is different. Can you show the edge to?

 

I think it's a cud...

 

Which? The first one or second one?

 

I don't have either yet. The 1899 is a VAM. Messydesk already confirmed that. This is a photo from VamWorld. VAM 6A.

 

The OP coin

 

I like collecting Morgan oddities. So I looked into this online. I'll have to see what it looks like when it arrives. There are Morgans out there with cuds that aren't VAMs. Found a pretty extreme one for sale. but doesn't make them valuable.

 

Just trying to learn. Wouldn't it be more conclusive seeing the edge too?

 

There's clearly a dent in the circumference of the coin at that spot, so I'm thinking rim damage.

 

The 84S is definitely a rim ding, classic presentation.

The 99 is a (very small) cud.

 

When it arrives, I'll take a photo. This is why I said buying off the internet is a form of gambling.

 

Yeah, possibly

 

....and a shoddy attempted repair.
Signed:
Sunshine

 

A hammer is a fix all for everything, you knew that right? If it fits, it ships.

 

On the 1899, when I see this look, I wonder if it could be a fin that folded over with circulation. Not really my world.