MS 64 is my guess for the blue label Anacs (and these do tend to have a bad reputation, but there are nice coins in these slabs).
Okay - Here is a tabulation of the guesses. I will post the reveal momentarily. Nobody got the right answer, but there were some really close guesses. 68 - 2 67FB - 2 67 - 1 66FB - 1 66 -1 65FB -1 65 - 4 64FB - 2 64 - 3 63FB - 1 58 - 1 Details - 1
Thanks for guessing everyone! ChristopherCollectsCoins got closest -- he guessed 63 but guessed FB. Honorable Mention to anyone that guessed 64.
It was fun reading through this thread. Usually, the Anacs grade would be given then have everyone guess the PCGS grade. But going backwards was a good twist.
How anyone would call a coin with that few contact marks and that clean of fields is beyond me. Not to mention the color being nice the full bands it’s close but I think it makes it