Message:

<p>[QUOTE=&quot;silverstream, post: 748134, member: 21592&quot;]I submitted a Morgan dollar to PCGS for grading which returned what I think is an impossible determination. </p><p>I had an original bank roll of Morgan Dollars which im certain were never opened. Every coin from that roll received a grade. But the rarest date and coin which was from that roll received a determination that it was genuine but cleaned. To me, its impossible that the coin was cleaned. It doesnt look cleaned to me but of course i dont claim to be as expert a grader as the folks at PCGS. But still Im certain that this roll had never been opened none of the other coins in the roll were determined to be or looked to be cleaned. A private dealer who looked at it also doesnt think it was cleaned. The roll contained several pl and dmpl&#039;s. </p><p>Can any of you give me an opinion of whether or not in your experience the grade can change upon resubmission with PCGS? </p><p>I have collected coins for over 30 years and have many handed down from the family. I have purchased graded coins but never ever submitted to a grading service until this roll. Im a bit disappointed and surprised that they have determined this coin to have been cleaned. I think its impossible unless it was done over a 100 years ago before it went into the roll and besides i see no signs of cleaning. I know the roll was never opened in the almost century my family had it.</p><p>&nbsp;</p><p>Are there conditions that can occur while within the roll that would give the appearance of cleaning?&nbsp; Appreciate your thoughts.[/QUOTE]</p><p><br /></p>

Your name or email address:

Do you already have an account?

• No, create an account now.
• Yes, my password is:
• Forgot your password?

Stay logged in