Log in or Sign up
Coin Talk
Home
Forums
>
Coin Forums
>
Coin Chat
>
Reporting on my ICG Submission
>
Reply to Thread
Message:
<p>[QUOTE="Seattlite86, post: 25384951, member: 59737"]Update: I received an email that the coins have already shipped! USPS says the label was created, but close enough! </p><p><br /></p><p>I was billed for a total of $425, which comes out to about $17 per coin, with a <b><u>very</u></b> gracious CoinTalk discount. That is quite incredible, considering 21 of the coins required conservation, and that includes return shipping.</p><p><br /></p><p>Below is the list of the coins, certification numbers, and the grades they received. I requested 5 coins to be photographed. I think I will likely need to wait until tomorrow for the images to appear in the database. I will be asleep before they upload. I added an asterisk to the coins I requested photographs for.</p><p><br /></p><p><b>CG Coin Number</b> <b>Year</b> <b>Denomination</b> <b>Prefix</b> <b>Suffix</b> <b>Variety</b> <b>Grade</b></p><p>955642-02-01 1915-S 5C MS 63*</p><p>955642-03-01 1918-S 5C AU 55*</p><p>955642-04-01 1915-D 5C F 15</p><p>955642-05-01 1937 5C MS 63</p><p>955642-06-01 1923 5C MS 63</p><p>955642-07-01 1914 5C VF 30 Details</p><p>955642-08-01 1914 5C EF 45</p><p>955642-09-02 1917 5C EF 45 Details</p><p>955642-10-01 1916 5C EF 40 Details</p><p>955642-10-03 1916 5C EF 45</p><p>955642-14-01 1999-P 25C MS GA, Partial Collar 63</p><p>955642-17-02 1913 5C AU Type 1 55</p><p>955642-17-03 1913 5C EF Type 1 40 Details</p><p>955642-18-01 1918 5C AU 55*</p><p>955642-01-01 1913 5C VF Type 2 25</p><p>955642-01-02 1913 5C AU Type 2 50</p><p>955642-07-02 1914 5C EF 40</p><p>955642-09-01 1917 5C AU 50 Details</p><p>955642-10-02 1916 5C VF 25</p><p>955642-11-01 1996-P 5C MS Struck Thru 61</p><p>955642-12-01 1913-D 5C VG Type 2 8 Details</p><p>955642-13-01 1989-P 25C AU On 10C Stock 58*</p><p>955642-15-01 1980-D 10C No Grade*</p><p>955642-16-01 1989-P 5C MS Partial Collar 60</p><p>955642-17-01 1913 5C EF Type 1 45 Details</p><p><br /></p><p>The 1915-S came back graded much higher than I anticipated. I cannot wait to see the photos of it after conservation! I was surprised the 1989-P 25C got a straight grade, as I thought I could detect counter wheel damage on it. I am curious how the photos will appear. I know the grades are not given the same weight as NGC and PCGS, so when I receive the coins and see the photographs, I will likely apply my own subjective grades to them.</p><p><br /></p><p>I was disappointed by the number of them that got details grades (7), but what can you do? They required a lot of conservation (which is why I sent them to ICG!). They also cost me 4.5 cents each, so even as details grade coins, I am not sure I could have purchased these coins for what I paid to have them conserved and slabbed.</p><p><br /></p><p>The most confusing is the 10C that got a no grade. I believe it to be a missing clad before strike. I am unsure if it is going to be in a slab, and/or if the no grade will get explained.</p><p><br /></p><p>Now comes the wait for the coins to return from across the globe (I live in Europe for those not tracking). Overall, the experience has been quite positive. I will update with ICG photos of the coins when I wake up (unless someone beats me to it).[/QUOTE]</p><p><br /></p>
[QUOTE="Seattlite86, post: 25384951, member: 59737"]Update: I received an email that the coins have already shipped! USPS says the label was created, but close enough! I was billed for a total of $425, which comes out to about $17 per coin, with a [B][U]very[/U][/B] gracious CoinTalk discount. That is quite incredible, considering 21 of the coins required conservation, and that includes return shipping. Below is the list of the coins, certification numbers, and the grades they received. I requested 5 coins to be photographed. I think I will likely need to wait until tomorrow for the images to appear in the database. I will be asleep before they upload. I added an asterisk to the coins I requested photographs for. [B]CG Coin Number[/B] [B]Year[/B] [B]Denomination[/B] [B]Prefix[/B] [B]Suffix[/B] [B]Variety[/B] [B]Grade[/B] 955642-02-01 1915-S 5C MS 63* 955642-03-01 1918-S 5C AU 55* 955642-04-01 1915-D 5C F 15 955642-05-01 1937 5C MS 63 955642-06-01 1923 5C MS 63 955642-07-01 1914 5C VF 30 Details 955642-08-01 1914 5C EF 45 955642-09-02 1917 5C EF 45 Details 955642-10-01 1916 5C EF 40 Details 955642-10-03 1916 5C EF 45 955642-14-01 1999-P 25C MS GA, Partial Collar 63 955642-17-02 1913 5C AU Type 1 55 955642-17-03 1913 5C EF Type 1 40 Details 955642-18-01 1918 5C AU 55* 955642-01-01 1913 5C VF Type 2 25 955642-01-02 1913 5C AU Type 2 50 955642-07-02 1914 5C EF 40 955642-09-01 1917 5C AU 50 Details 955642-10-02 1916 5C VF 25 955642-11-01 1996-P 5C MS Struck Thru 61 955642-12-01 1913-D 5C VG Type 2 8 Details 955642-13-01 1989-P 25C AU On 10C Stock 58* 955642-15-01 1980-D 10C No Grade* 955642-16-01 1989-P 5C MS Partial Collar 60 955642-17-01 1913 5C EF Type 1 45 Details The 1915-S came back graded much higher than I anticipated. I cannot wait to see the photos of it after conservation! I was surprised the 1989-P 25C got a straight grade, as I thought I could detect counter wheel damage on it. I am curious how the photos will appear. I know the grades are not given the same weight as NGC and PCGS, so when I receive the coins and see the photographs, I will likely apply my own subjective grades to them. I was disappointed by the number of them that got details grades (7), but what can you do? They required a lot of conservation (which is why I sent them to ICG!). They also cost me 4.5 cents each, so even as details grade coins, I am not sure I could have purchased these coins for what I paid to have them conserved and slabbed. The most confusing is the 10C that got a no grade. I believe it to be a missing clad before strike. I am unsure if it is going to be in a slab, and/or if the no grade will get explained. Now comes the wait for the coins to return from across the globe (I live in Europe for those not tracking). Overall, the experience has been quite positive. I will update with ICG photos of the coins when I wake up (unless someone beats me to it).[/QUOTE]
Your name or email address:
Do you already have an account?
No, create an account now.
Yes, my password is:
Forgot your password?
Stay logged in
Coin Talk
Home
Forums
>
Coin Forums
>
Coin Chat
>
Reporting on my ICG Submission
>
Home
Home
Quick Links
Search Forums
Recent Activity
Recent Posts
Forums
Forums
Quick Links
Search Forums
Recent Posts
Competitions
Competitions
Quick Links
Competition Index
Rules, Terms & Conditions
Gallery
Gallery
Quick Links
Search Media
New Media
Showcase
Showcase
Quick Links
Search Items
Most Active Members
New Items
Directory
Directory
Quick Links
Directory Home
New Listings
Members
Members
Quick Links
Notable Members
Current Visitors
Recent Activity
New Profile Posts
Sponsors
Menu
Search
Search titles only
Posted by Member:
Separate names with a comma.
Newer Than:
Search this thread only
Search this forum only
Display results as threads
Useful Searches
Recent Posts
More...