http://www.ebay.com/itm/Pony-House-125-South-Jefferson-Street-Dayton-Ohio-1900-1919-Good-Token-/400268101692#ht_500wt_1156
Tokens like this are hard to value because most aren't listed in reference books Jackie. The best way to get an estimate of value is to do what you did, check auction sites, eBay or the internet to see what others sold for. The $30 price seems high like Rick says, but the $4 is pretty cheap. Bruce
A lot of them are listed, but you have to have the right reference books. You typically have to have the book for that particular state. Unfortunatel most of them are small run publications and out of print making them hard to find. This site has a nice list of titles which can help you in your search for the books. http://www.louisiana-trade-tokens.com/books.html