I agree 100%. There's a strong chance that it would not survive resubmission in today's climate. Also, I have no problem paying a premium for nice toning. However, the seller is way to high on this coin IMO. If you really want the coin, I'd point out the PCGS price guide and offer double that. Personally, on a common date like this, I don't think the coin is worth any more of an extra premium.
Even as an MS65, I think he is looking for way too much for that coin. As is, it looks like a $125-$150 coin to me. And when I am that far off from what a seller is seeking, I walk away, rather than beat my head against the wall.