Reply to Thread

Message:: [QUOTE="CamaroDMD, post: 4588334, member: 5233"]I think there are two reasons to look at this...one as a buyer and one as a seller. As a buyer, personally I want as much info as possible about the coin on the slab.  As long as I know that this was not done by PCGS and am confident that it is attributed correctly (and my faith in PCGS attributing something correctly is not that high anyway) I'm OK with it.  But that's OCD me.  If I bought this coin thinking that it was attributed by PCGS I'd probably be mad when I got it.  That being said, it's pretty obvious what it is from the photo and if that was the issue then it's at least 50% on me. As a seller, I feel like there is really little upside to this.  I feel that it will only cause confusion and anger a buyer.  Best case is they say nothing...so there is no upside.  So, as a seller, I would remove it. As an informed owner/buyer...I'd leave it as is. I don't really see much deception here personally.[/QUOTE]