Questionable Color - any experience resubmitting?

Love it.

I NEARLY "liked' it!

 

Log in or Sign up to hide this ad.

Even after Doug finally liked yours?... Oh wait... Sorry

 

Funny boy!

I'm gonna put you on my list!

 

I assume you mean Christmas card list, thanks, I really appreciate that.

 

Hello, and welcome to the forum.

 

So, if PCGS is right that it's QC, would it behoove razor to consider having the coin dipped? In your opinion, is the coloring possibly covering some other degree of damage?

 

No, my humble opinion is that the QC is the result of being dipped. It's not AT.

 

Ahh, okay. That actually makes a lot of sense. In that case, is it possible the owner should just keep the coin as is, since subsequent submissions might result in environmental damage designations instead of questionable color?

 

I guess it depends on what the coin looks like in hand, it appeared somewhat unnatural in the images. I think that a little time out of the slab could potentially result in a RB designation which would be a great score. Of course I am not the authority on this, just my personal opinion.

 

I should have it tomorrow. If I do, then I'll take accurate photos and send them to you @Kirkuleez for some additional input. I can also send them to you @NorthKorea if you're interested.
Thanks again.

 

I won't be of much help, since the coin is copper. You really should just post the photos here.