Here is the only coin I have in a rattle holder, an 1864 large motto Two Cent Piece. The coin is graded MS-65, Red. I am not a rattle holder fan. They are smalled than other slabs, which complicates storeage, and the coins often, well, rattled in them which I don't like. I've cracked out a few of them for upgrades, which always worked, and actually had a couple of pieces put in new holders because I didn't like the venue.