A naturally toned SMS (Special Mint Set) And a naturally toned proof... compared to an artificially toned proof. At least, I assume it is AT, since I bought 25 of these proofs with assorted toning that represented 25 consecutive years. They cost 11 cents each.
I had a *real* hard time getting photos of this myself which adequately captured the color. Lucky for me, TrueView was able to do just that --
Unless the back of that coin drags it into the dregs, that coin should be graded, common date or not.
Yes it is raw. Personally I would call it AU-58 or so. It has the lightest rub on the tail and hip of the Buffalo. But it has the color I have been looking for in a Buffalo for a very long time. I love it!