I think each of us is arguing a different thing. If a doubled die cannot be confirmed because of the condition of the coin, then I agree it should not be listed. The same goes for your worn down cent example. If it cannot be confirmed as a 1909-S VDB, it should not be listed as such. I'm still confused, however, what this has to do with the original topic. The doubling of the eyelid is visible in the pictures. Would it still be visible if the coin was G-04? I don't know, but that's beside the point. You also still have yet to give proof that the coin in the listing is unverifiable as a doubled die...
the proof is simple. with my reaosnably young, 20/20 eyes, and those seller pictures, i do not see any double die. i see a beat up, smooth copper planchet that used to be a lincoln cent.
Here is a picture of one of the markers to identify this Double Die for that person that is basicaly calling me a liar about it being a double die..This is from the same coin i have listed on ebay..
i applaud you for putting ego aside. a rare thing on this forum. truth be told, i just dont see the doubling, my reasoning being i feel the coin is too worn. cool?
I've never heard of this before: Floating roof? http://www.ebay.com/itm/GEM-BU-1965...95?pt=Coins_US_Individual&hash=item334363e4c3
Yes, I understand and respect that. That being said, I do see the doubling, the seller sees the doubling, and I am sure that quite a few of the members here also see the doubling. Bigrig52 also posted an identifying die marker on this thread. Coupled with the fact that from what I see the doubling is evident in the pictures in the listing (just look where the arrow is pointing), I still stand by his assessment in calling it a DDO. It does take a trained eye to pick out the doubling sometimes, and maybe that is why some people are not seeing it right away.
well, then i just dont like the seller...for being able to identify coins i cannot and his/her breath smells like eggs, like, all the time
Well what ever i did to him really set him off..My bad breath is not from eggs it is from garlic or onions.I have to eat something while looking at coins and keep people like you away from me..hahahahah
Wittgenstein said, "Whereof one cannot speak, thereof one must be silent." A lot of you here should heed that advice. These coins are not only doubled dies, but as has been pointed out, they are correctly attributed. Here's a thread basically slandering a seller and it's based upon nothing but ignorance. You may not collect what is being offered, but there are plenty of people out there who do.
i think i struck a nerve.....with a quote from pitch perfect none the less! looks like he joined CT just in time too....hmmmmm
Thanks for helping me out..I don't worry about what people say about my auctions.As it says if they are not pleased with the item(s) they can return them..I try my best to give a good description and picture(s) of the item..I'm not perfect but i try..I think there are just a lot of jealous people because they can't find them..Oh well
first off, if you read what i wrote, here it is again...."well, then i just dont like the seller...for being able to identify coins i cannot" it is a nod to his sharp eye over mine, not an insult. second, knowing how picky and anal some can be here, i tagged it along with an overtly humorous quote to cement the non-offensiveness of the comment, and third, most importantly, i assure you i am not jealous of your $4 coins.
I didn't mean any disrespect to anyone..I just joined this group today and i get a bashing right off the bat..I didn't start this crap..Someone emailed me from somewhere else and said someone on this site was talking about my items on ebay and i just wanted to see what was up..I do my best on what i sell..I'm sorry for misunderstanding what you wrote but it has been a long day and i appoligize..I know they are real low priced coins but it helps me with my living needs..
Sorry guys for even starting this thread, I just have never even heard of double die eyelids and I could not see the double die on the images. All I am trying t say is that next time I make a thread that is something as dumb as this. All I was doing was pointing out the fact that people actually buy that kind of stuff and in my opinion it is just ridiculous. And sorry bigrig52 for making your first day so bad. Hope this thread die's and you will be happy here on CT.
welcome to CT brother. best advice i can give, grow thick skin if you plan on hanging around...i speak from experience