Poll: Which 1864 2 Cent should I keep for the type set?

Was trying a few different lighting setups since I had two of the same type/year here and figured I'd make a poll for fun to see what coin you all lean towards. I try to keep things problem free in this set, but since I picked up Coin A thinking it was a variety (it wasn't) here we are.

This page of my 7070 is always going to be mixed anyway as I can't find a circulated steel cent that isn't ugly and a high-end Classic Head ain't happenin', so the context is fine for either.

I'm not certain about the spot removal but that's my guess as to what happened there on the obverse left by the looks of it.

Coin A:
Coin B:


Coin A (alternate lighting #1) :

Coin B (alternate lighting #1) :


Coin A (alternate lighting #2) :


Coin B (alternate lighting #2) :


Thanks!

 

Log in or Sign up to hide this ad.

I voted coin B. It's XF40, which is a totally respectable grade for a type set! I like the 1st one, but that spot grabs your attention. If it were on the reverse, I may have voted Coin A.

 

I like the first two images the best. To me, they have a more natural look. I would put Coin B in the album because I feel Coin A is the better coin. I'm not much for putting my better coins in the 7070.
I'm not sure about Coin A but it could have been someone with a Q-tip trying to help it. I would lay it on my desk outside of a holder and just watch it for a few months. The brighter area may darken. The really dark spot will always be there but a doctor could change the brighter area back to brown really quick.
It's really nice just the way it is.

 

I like A better but I'm no expert.

 

Love the strike on coin “A”...... Howeever it that one don’t win your vote.... PM me!

 

Coin A is still nicer and I wouldn't personally mind the spot but pick what you like!

 

Looks like coin B may have some verdigris on it which can progress and get worse. So I would stick with coin A.

 

I go A, because B looks like it may have been cleaned at one time.
And I like A more anyway even if B has not been cleaned, I prefer the color on A and the details.
There is that one rub on the left side on the reverse.

 

Coin "C" would be my choice, as well, but since we have to choose...It would depend on what you're going to do with the other coin, plus what you paid for each, as well as how they compare to other coins in the set.

To me, coin "B" has a more natural look, but it has problems. I don't like the color on the obverse of coin "A". Something has been done to it.

Keep in mind that I am barely an amateur, let alone a novice or better, lol.

 

I'll take a couple no-frills snaps of both later... I don't see any problems in hand with B but it looks more natural in-hand than in the photos. I'm an ongoing work in progress when it comes to photographing this stuff.

 

And thanks for all the comments/opinions so far!

I have a harder time selecting with this one because the design isn't my favorite (besides the IN GOD WE TRUST part and I like that this was the first year) so I don't get "grabbed" by them in general.

 

Your pictures are MUCH better than the pics I take with the ipad and post, lol.

 

I always tend to lean in favor of the problem-free coin.

Is looking for another example in your wheelhouse? If so, I’m with @lordmarcovan Keep looking.

 

Haha, yes the almighty CircCam will always win with me. I haven't found one of these with that look yet without problems.

 

Ok, I tried to take these in the @Eduard -ian style.

Coin A loses its nice sheen in this type of lighting (natural, window sill) but Coin B deserved to be done justice and these show how it actually looks in hand.

 

I’m still slobbering over A. It’s just a clean and solid strike to me.