Planchet flaws.

Hey everyone
I was wondering would a coin with planchet flaws be considered a problem or details coin ?

 

Log in or Sign up to hide this ad.

From what I can tell, it depends on how bad the flaws are. If they believe that slabbing the coin would cause more problems, they will body bad it.

 

Do you have a pic of the coin?

 

Depends on the flaw . Pic please .

 

I have a 1918 Buffalo nickel with lamination and NGC noted it on the label .

 

It actually added value , correct .

 

It was a buffalo nickel, I was thinking of bidding on. It's in a slab PcI it says planchet flaws. I believe there problem slabs are red the coin in question is in one of there green label holders I was just wondering.

 

Rusty I'm going to have to pull it out I can't recall it may be an 18 D .

 

I have a 1856-D half eagle with a reverse planchet flaw and NGC put it in a details holder, looks like a lamination to me, and errors with the planchets were common for this year and denomination, but guess it was too distracting for them to put it in a normal holder

 

If it was a problem coin it would be in a red holder