Nice coin, BUT.................

What would you grade it at? Yes, they are really there. With a loupe, they are even more obvious.

 

Log in or Sign up to hide this ad.

Rev is a beauty = 65 -66
Obverse is more important = 63-64 due to spots.

If the coin is original than I think the very tiny amount of "cabinet friction" on Lincoln and perhaps a few random hairlines will be ignored. My personal grade: 63 Red TPGS: possibly 64.

Looks like the coin is already graded...by ICG? Then I'll guess TPGS = 65 Red - but just.

 

Actually it is an old PCI slab, but I am not asking what the TPG graded it. I am looking for what grade YOU would give it.

 

MS 64+ nice coin. Might be higher.

 

What happened to the 2?

 

65.

 

If is yours or just wasting my time don't ask questions you should know. If you don't.. Let me let you in on a little secret... SUSH HERE IT IS.... Gather up 4 more and turn it in to NGC and get your own answer. "Genuine" Ex fine details...

 

64

 

It's a 63 to me.

 

Au -58

 

63RD. The worst spots are on the face, and that kills it for me.

 

I'm assuming the "they" you are referring to are the spots on the obverse? It looks like someone sneezed on the coin, unfortunately. The rest of the coin looks quite attractive, but the spots limit the grade to 63RD for me.

 

I agree with 63 RD. The reverse saves it

 

Am I seeing rim dings on the reverse or is that just the holder design? It looks like rim dings. On a mint state coin such as this, that would be enough to body bag it. BLAH!

Otherwise, I'm not good at designating the level of mint state, but I would say low-mid MS and Red.

 

There is a small nick in front of it. Other than that, it is just the lighting

 

Just the holder.

 

65RD

 

Already did...first thing.

 

?

 

When do you tell us?