Message:

<p>[QUOTE=&quot;HowardStern, post: 1224476, member: 26533&quot;]Over the past year Ive sent in quite a few Buchanan dollar coins with very weak edge errors.&nbsp; They were all from the same box and extremely weak.&nbsp; NGC acknowledged them as such.</p><p>[ATTACH]130204.vB[/ATTACH](whats the S$1)</p><p>I had a few more I saved to send in when I had the money.&nbsp; Once I saved, I had to resubscribe to NGC in order to get them graded.&nbsp; 45 days later I recieve them back in slabs with no error grade!!!&nbsp; They were all the same weakness as the others 100%!&nbsp; I called NGC and was told they no longer grade weak edges and havent for a few years now. I said thats funny because 2 months ago you did...for me!&nbsp; The error grader had to call me back I was told.&nbsp; He told me that they made a mistake in grading my buchanan weak edges in the past.&nbsp; I said thats all fine and dandy but you screwed me pretty bad with the ones I just sent in.&nbsp; I have no use for ms64-ms66 graded non error presidential dollars.&nbsp; Now I have error coins slabbed by NGC with no error acknowledged..only weak grades. I was offered a partial refund..not a full one.&nbsp; I went up the chain and finally got a full refund from them.</p><p>Should I crack the ones they graded and send them in to another company?</p><p>I dont know what to think?&nbsp; I guess I cant be mad since , not only did I get the refund, but now the weak edged buchanans that they actually acknowledged as errors must be pretty darn rare! Im mad that I already sold a few!</p><p>Not only are they the last to ever get the NGC weak edge error, but they stopped grading them as such over 2 years ago, and NGC acknowledged a mistake!</p><p>What should I do?[/QUOTE]</p><p><br /></p>

Your name or email address:

Do you already have an account?

• No, create an account now.
• Yes, my password is:
• Forgot your password?

Stay logged in