At any rate, it is a nice coin. The overall impression is of a softly struck Peace Dollar of gem quality. The devices are decently struck, with some grainy quality and a quite a bit of softness to them, as was expected. The fields are nice and clear (marks are on the flip, which were exaggerated by the direct flash, necessitated by today's weather). Would I consider it a good coin in terms of the quality of minting and the overall impression of the design? Yes, definitely. It does look like a Peace Dollar, with some lack of symmetry due to the overstrike situation. The lettering doesn't line up perfectly, and there is a softness to the motto on the reverse. However, it is a pleasing coin. Overall, I would call it a successful venture, and apologize to Mr. Carr for any negative comments made, regarding it appearing as a poor quality reproduction. It is NOT so--it is a good, solid restrike, that I am happy to have in my collection. I was wrong in my previous opinions.