Reply to Thread

Message:: [QUOTE="Nathan B., post: 7874768, member: 112852"][ATTACH=full]1357133[/ATTACH] "Buy the book before the coin," they said.  Well, I bought the coin first (my avatar, a lovely Athenian tetradrachm).  But then I bought a book, and then another, and then two more, and then several more.  It was only after I bought these that I picked up a Menander drachm, and then a number of very affordable ancients, some in group lots, some just singles, in AMCC3.  These are my "learning coins" at this point.  But now for the books. First, though: be warned! This is a long post and is written from my personal viewpoint as a learner. My very first coin book is one that many will know, and to be honest, I actually recommend it despite its considerable limitations: Zander Klawans Handbook of Ancient Greek & Roman Coins.  This book has glossy, high quality pages that are a joy to touch and turn; these pages have many beautiful, if small, black and white images of coins.  The book also has a number of useful features, including an extremely helpful introduction to how coins were minted, a table of Greek letters and numbers, information on the relationships between denominations for both Greek and also Roman coins, and an alphabetical list of names of Emperors as they frequently appear on Roman coins.  In all honesty, the main reason I chose this book as my entry point was simply because it was cheap and easy to find on Amazon! The next book I bought was Paul Rynearson's Collecting Ancient Greek Coins: A Guided Tour Featuring 25 Significant Types. From the perspective of someone who is new to ancient (Greek) coins, I can say that this book is outstanding, even if I have a few quibbles here and there about things that could have made the book a little easier to follow. The field of ancient (Greek) numismatics is so broad that it be very overwhelming.  Rynearson breaks this problem down into manageable chunks, first with general essays on topics like historical background, artistic themes, how Greek coins are catalogued and graded; forgeries, building one's collection, and so on. He then proceeds to give a brief overview of 25 significant types, such as Aegina's Turtles and Athens' Owls (both international coinages), the "boy on a dolphin" design of Taras, the bee design on Ephesians' coins, and so on.  There are numerous pictures in full colour, including a special section at the back that shows them in relative sizes.  A small but very handy glossary rounds out this most worthy book.  I cannot recommend it highly enough to the beginner or novice! The third book I read was Wayne Sayles' Ancient Coin Collecting (2nd ed.), the first book in a series by him on collecting ancients.  Although some parts of this book have dated (e.g. any discussion of the internet), Sayles' book remains very useful in giving a very broad overview of ancient Greek, Roman, Byzantine, and even (very briefly) non-classical cultures' coins--and the collecting of those coins. There are very informative tables (e.g. a list of Roman emperors, and a wonderful section on abstract personfications on Roman coins).  Topics include history, how to create a library and learn more; attributing and dating coins, both Greek and Roman; how to build a collection, and so on.  The book is dense, but not too dry.  Unlike the first two books, though, this book has a far higher ratio of text to images, and the images are of much lesser quality than those in the two books I've described above.  Still: it's worth the read. All three of the above works have some overlap, which is good for a beginner collector: more reinforcement! While I will come to Sayles' second book in this series, a work on collecting Greek coins a bit later, right now, I am reading David Sear's new book An Introductory Guide to Ancient Greek & Roman Coins: Volume 1 Greek Civic Coins & Tribal Issues. It's worth noting that although this book is aimed at novices as well as collectors with some experience, it approaches pedagogy in a much different way from any of the titles described so far.  It begins with a preface intended for the whole series, so if you're interested only in Greek coins, you will be surprised to find a lot of talk of Roman coins and Roman history as well as their Greek counterparts. Immediately following this is an alphabetically-organized glossary that goes on for forty pages! At first, I questioned the wisdom of this approach: wouldn't it be better to arrange the material thematically?  Or if not, then to put the glossary in the back, as is more customary?  I think the reason that Sear wants it put up front is because this book covers a much vaster set of data than, say, Rynearson's book with its more pedagogical approach.  You simply need to read through it before you go on.  And to be sure, it is interesting and informative. Following that, Sear then covers, in discrete chapters, the world of Greek coinage, starting with Celtic coinage (which for beginners is often lumped in with Greek coinage).  In doing so, he is not making much concession to the beginner collector and reader, who may be wanting a more systematic introduction to topics in a way that allows one step to build off another.  However, Sear is still doing the reader a favour because this is actually the standard order used in the industry, for example, by auction catalogues.  One simply has to get used to it, so this is as good a time as any. The text is dryer than Rynearson's, but still readable, and not difficult, except in one way: one will often read about some coin in a western area that actually got there only after being introduced in an eastern area.  This makes a "proper introduction" to each coin sometimes a bit difficulty.  On a more positive note, the book is lavishly illustrated, with nearly every page in this section sporting multiple full colour, high quality images in the margins.  The pages are also glossy and smooth, which is always nice! I've only just begun the chapters on discrete areas, and I'm still wondering how to approach it, due to the sheer amount of information provided.  Should I take copious notes, as I have with each book I've read until now?  Or should I just skim it and then read it, or even just look at the pictures, and then read it?  So far, I've been going the copious notes route, but I don't know if I can or will continue that; I'm getting a bit impatient.  Perhaps I will read Sayles' book on Greek coins first, and then come back to this one. One thing I do know, though: this book is essential if one wants to understand Greek coinage.  My advice for the novice is to start with Rynearson's carefully-focused work, like a beginner should, and then move on to this more intermediate-level book at some point after.  There's a lot of data to get acquainted with, a lot of coins to see and learn about.  But that's why we're reading the book, isn't it?  Insofar as this book introduces all these coins, it performs a valuable service. Some time ago, I saw two titles in a list of books ancient collectors are "supposed to" buy, so I bought them.  One is Christopher Howgego's Ancient History from Coins; the other is a gorgeous coffee table book 100 Greatest Ancient Coins (2nd edition), by Harlan Berk.  This is a lavishly illustrated book that is a joy to look at and to read.  That said, I'm sure many will quibble with certain coins being excluded, or with the ranking order.  That's fine.  Just enjoy the book, because that's what it's for, and ranking can be subjective anyway. One thing I did appreciate is Berk's comment that even though some of the coins he includes in his list are four or even five figures in price (putting them forever out of the reach of most collectors, including me), collectors still need to know these coins! Indeed, the larger coins of Syracuse, in particular, are widely considered among the best and most beautiful coins ever minted. I think one could say that the engravers of the dies were more talented than most engravers, or even all, today. The next books I bought are all reference works, and some of them came in very handy when I tried to find out more about my first Greek bronzes, small, tiny, and often worn.  The first I wish to discuss is David Sear's 1978 2-volume catalogue Greek Coins and their Values. The values, of course, are completely out of date, but it's the catalogue that matters.  This is not the sort of book you'd read cover-to-cover (although I guess one could, and it would certainly be a very informative experience).  The organization of this set follows the standard approach of looking at a geographical area, and then within that area, looking diachronically before moving on to the next area.  What I've found hardest in using it is trying to find which cities are in which chapters; the table of contents helps with this, but not completely.  Essentially, you need to know the region the city that minted your coin was in. (I also bought Sear's Greek Imperial Coins and their Values, because they were part of a special sale from Charles Davis's numismatic books shop on Vcoins.com.  The sale and selection may be different, but I really do recommend this store and the service that Charles Davis provided me.) I do strongly urge those new to attributing ancient Greek coins to buy one book when they come to Sear, and that work is Greek Coin Types and their Identification, by Richard Plant.  This is a wonderful resource for those who are looking to identify and attribute coins.  It is divided into two parts: a list of coins and their designs, and a set of black and white drawings of those coins.  The way the book works is that you look up the reverse design according to various categories, for example, two figures, one armed figure, horseman, horse alone, grapes, etc.  Your eyes can quickly scan the diagrams on the pages in question, and then when you find the coin that matches yours, you just look up the corresponding number in the list.  Using that information, it is then much easier to track down information in the Sear catalogue.  I have found that Plant's book, while it can't possibly contain all or even most Greek coins, is definitely useful.  I recommend it very highly. I only need to mention three more books, or maybe four.  About two years ago, I went to my local university library and photocopied John Melville-Jones's entire Testimonia Numaria, Vol. 1. I had no ethical problems doing so because the book is out of print, and typically sells for a few hundred dollars or more.  When I was looking, I couldn't even find one available at any price.  Anyway, what this book is is a collection of excerpts of ancient Greek texts about money.  The experience of reading all these primary source texts (which are often bite-sized, though not always) was extremely pleasurable for me, as well as eye-opening.  If you can, buy the book.  As for the publisher, Spink, I really hope they do get with the program and reprint it.  They could even offer a digital download.  This work is far too important and useful to be beyond the reach of 99% of ancient Greek coin collectors. I did manage to get my hands on Melville-Jones's Vol. 2, though, which is his commentary on the texts in Volume 1.  I haven't read it yet, but I will at some point look at it. The penultimate book I will mention is another Melville-Jones work: A Dictionary of Ancient Greek Coins. This book has excellent reviews, and is supposed to be a must-have for anyone interested in learning about ancient Greek coins.  I believe the reviews, but I haven't looked at it yet.  That said, I wish that this book was available electronically, and thematically arranged for pedagogical purposes.  Then, one could still use it as a reference simply by searching for the particular term one needs to understand.  In any case, I'm glad to have it in my little library. The final book I need to mention is a more specialist work--because I am interested in Indo-Greek and Bactrian coinage.  At present I have only one Indo-Greek coin type (a Menander drachm), so I am once again buying one coin, and then a book, before further purchases (which I can't afford right now anyway).  This book is from the Classical Numismatic Group's "Handbook of Greek Coinage" series, and it is the Handbook of Coins of Baktria and Ancient India, by Oliver Hoover.  There is a very positive forward to the book by the biggest name in the field, Osmund Bopearachchi. For those wondering what this is all about, when Alexander the Great conquered his empire, he left troops who settled down in places that we now know as countries like Uzbekistan, Afghanistan, Pakistan, and even India. After Alexander died, his general Seleucus managed to acquire these lands for his great Hellenistic kingdom. Eventually, one of the local satraps (governors) rebelled against the Seleucids, and founded an independent kingdom of Bactria.  Later, the Greeks expanded into Pakistan and eventually northern India, and Bactria itself was lost to invading tribes. The most famous king who ruled the Indo-Greek kingdom at its height was Menander, about whom I have already written here on <a href="https://www.cointalk.com/threads/a-trip-around-the-world-through-time-from-my-second-ancient-coin-a-menander-drachm.374878/" class="internalLink ProxyLink" data-proxy-href="https://www.cointalk.com/threads/a-trip-around-the-world-through-time-from-my-second-ancient-coin-a-menander-drachm.374878/">CoinTalk</a>.  Menander, who conquered much more of India than Alexander the Great did, is notable for being attested in Greek and Latin sources, as well as for being the central character of an Indian work of Buddhist philosophy, The Questions of King Milinda. I haven't read the work yet, but know that it is extant in both a Pali and also a Chinese version; the work presents Menander as a convert to Buddhism, which is remarkable in itself. So that is my library at present.  I no longer consider myself a beginner in Greek coinage.  Maybe "lower intermediate" would describe where I am now.  At this point, I think it's important just to get one's eyes on as many coins as possible.  A good way to do this is just to browse the coins at Vcoins!  I found it fun to organize them by price from low to high; that way, I learned what my hard-earned dollars can with the passage of time afford.  Meanwhile, I continue to read, and to journal my reading. If anyone is interested in where I purchased these books, quite a few came from Charles Davis's Vcoins store.  Quite a few others came from Amazon.  In one case, I had to find a used copy from an independent bookseller. How about you?  Please feel free to share your libraries and your learning techniques, because I and other new collectors here can use all the help we can get!  Cheers.[/QUOTE]

Create my FREE Account!

Log in or Sign up

Reply to Thread

Useful Searches