Log in or Sign up
Coin Talk
Home
Forums
>
Coin Forums
>
Coin Chat
>
LOOK WHAT JUST SOLD FOR $1,884.02
>
Reply to Thread
Message:
<p>[QUOTE="Bruce Jonathan Fick, post: 2098139, member: 73845"]Imho, though am anything but an experienced seasoned expert</p><p>on Morgan dollars, I do collect the rare dates & mintmarks in MS</p><p>and the espercialy the DMPLs in high MS grades ( above MS 64 )</p><p>So I've researched as much as I can absorb on the topic of Chinese</p><p>counterfeits. And this 1901 Morgan looks like a forged reproduction...</p><p>Ditto the holder. It's no secret that there's a state of the art factory</p><p>somewhere in China that cranks out an alarming number of rare</p><p>date Morgans from forged dies. And that they've been flooding the</p><p>USA with expertly made counterfeits. Unless someone is dilligent </p><p>in comparing them side by side with an authentic one, it's too easy</p><p>to be conned. We know that in the 1921 Morgans Liberty appears </p><p>differently than in 1904. The 1921 appears more masculine than</p><p>the original school teacher who modled for Chief Engraver Morgan.</p><p><br /></p><p>Only going on a hunch here, but the mouth of Liberty seems to me</p><p>at least to appear different than a genuine 1901. Check out the 1895</p><p>Proof that Kazuma78 has photoed as his avatar immage. The upper</p><p>lip of Liberty seems 180 degrees, yet the bottom lip seems angled at</p><p>135 degrees downward. On a normal business strike both lips should </p><p>flare out the top lip up, the bottom lip downward. The lips on Liberty's mouth appear recessed inward on this fake. I'd expect more definition</p><p>of the Eagle's feathers for a genuine Philadelphia Mint 1901. This fake</p><p>has the breast feather pattern of a 1921 ; the feathers are very weak</p><p>like a New Orleans Minted Morgan. Wierd. Unless I'm seeing things,</p><p>these are my observations. </p><p><br /></p><p>Also, the only genuine 1901 MS Morgans I've ever seen have genuine</p><p>NGC or PCGS holders which are a known target for counterfeiters. And</p><p>it seems odd that a genuine 1901 would be auctioned at less than a</p><p>Heritage or Stacks & Bowers auction house which is a reputable place</p><p>to bid on a 1901 MS Morgan. If I have my facts straight, the Treasury</p><p>melted the MS Morgans stored closest to the vault doors during WW1.</p><p>Making the 1901 exceptionaly rare in any grade of MS. I've always seen</p><p>reputable coin dealers offer them on a Buy It Now basis on Ebay. No</p><p>need for anyone to feel sick they missed out on this fake as it's far far better to have your $1800+ of cash than $0000- of nothing, and worse</p><p>knowing you've been taken by Fraudsters. You can always make up the bread, but the humiliation of being defrauded will linger a lot longer, no?[/QUOTE]</p><p><br /></p>
[QUOTE="Bruce Jonathan Fick, post: 2098139, member: 73845"]Imho, though am anything but an experienced seasoned expert on Morgan dollars, I do collect the rare dates & mintmarks in MS and the espercialy the DMPLs in high MS grades ( above MS 64 ) So I've researched as much as I can absorb on the topic of Chinese counterfeits. And this 1901 Morgan looks like a forged reproduction... Ditto the holder. It's no secret that there's a state of the art factory somewhere in China that cranks out an alarming number of rare date Morgans from forged dies. And that they've been flooding the USA with expertly made counterfeits. Unless someone is dilligent in comparing them side by side with an authentic one, it's too easy to be conned. We know that in the 1921 Morgans Liberty appears differently than in 1904. The 1921 appears more masculine than the original school teacher who modled for Chief Engraver Morgan. Only going on a hunch here, but the mouth of Liberty seems to me at least to appear different than a genuine 1901. Check out the 1895 Proof that Kazuma78 has photoed as his avatar immage. The upper lip of Liberty seems 180 degrees, yet the bottom lip seems angled at 135 degrees downward. On a normal business strike both lips should flare out the top lip up, the bottom lip downward. The lips on Liberty's mouth appear recessed inward on this fake. I'd expect more definition of the Eagle's feathers for a genuine Philadelphia Mint 1901. This fake has the breast feather pattern of a 1921 ; the feathers are very weak like a New Orleans Minted Morgan. Wierd. Unless I'm seeing things, these are my observations. Also, the only genuine 1901 MS Morgans I've ever seen have genuine NGC or PCGS holders which are a known target for counterfeiters. And it seems odd that a genuine 1901 would be auctioned at less than a Heritage or Stacks & Bowers auction house which is a reputable place to bid on a 1901 MS Morgan. If I have my facts straight, the Treasury melted the MS Morgans stored closest to the vault doors during WW1. Making the 1901 exceptionaly rare in any grade of MS. I've always seen reputable coin dealers offer them on a Buy It Now basis on Ebay. No need for anyone to feel sick they missed out on this fake as it's far far better to have your $1800+ of cash than $0000- of nothing, and worse knowing you've been taken by Fraudsters. You can always make up the bread, but the humiliation of being defrauded will linger a lot longer, no?[/QUOTE]
Your name or email address:
Do you already have an account?
No, create an account now.
Yes, my password is:
Forgot your password?
Stay logged in
Coin Talk
Home
Forums
>
Coin Forums
>
Coin Chat
>
LOOK WHAT JUST SOLD FOR $1,884.02
>
Home
Home
Quick Links
Search Forums
Recent Activity
Recent Posts
Forums
Forums
Quick Links
Search Forums
Recent Posts
Competitions
Competitions
Quick Links
Competition Index
Rules, Terms & Conditions
Gallery
Gallery
Quick Links
Search Media
New Media
Showcase
Showcase
Quick Links
Search Items
Most Active Members
New Items
Directory
Directory
Quick Links
Directory Home
New Listings
Members
Members
Quick Links
Notable Members
Current Visitors
Recent Activity
New Profile Posts
Sponsors
Menu
Search
Search titles only
Posted by Member:
Separate names with a comma.
Newer Than:
Search this thread only
Search this forum only
Display results as threads
Useful Searches
Recent Posts
More...