With the new year, I decided to raid the same dealer to see if I could get any more bargain upgrades. I pretty much raided all the Gem cents he had, but his Choice cents were also really nice, so I got a couple of them too. There was one date that still had a Gem in stock: the 1955-D Lincoln. This is the coin I was hoping to upgrade. There isn't really much wrong with it, other than some spotting on both sides. This replacement cost $4.86 including shipping. It has light die scratches on the reverse, with nearly flawless fields on the obverse. There aren't any dings, but a couple of places where planchet roughness shows through. It looks really good compared to the MS67's on the NGC set registry. Full resolution photos. It's hard to believe, but an MS67 lists for $1350 on the NGC Price Guide. An MS66 is a big step down, at only $47. Whichever grade this is, it improves my set and is replacing the one in my album.
I saw a listing for a 1952-D in Choice condition, so I thought I would see if it was better than this one in my set. It is well struck and relatively unmarked, but has spotting developing on both sides. It looks like a little corrosion may be setting in on the right wheat ear. This replacement cost $6.32 with shipping. The surfaces are clean and silky, without any spotting. There is a ding along Lincoln's cheekbone, but it is nearly camouflaged because it lies along the design. Here are the full resolution photos. The replacement has already taken its place in my set. The original really looks great in hand with a great color and luster. The new one is just that little bit better. Price guide (from NGC Coin Explorer: 1952 D 1C MS) is $35 for MS66 and $530 for MS67.
I got three coins in my Dec. 31 order. The 52-D and 55-D have already been shown. The third coin was listed as a Choice 1954-S. I thought it might be better than the one I have in my set. For $5.16 I got this one. NGC's price guide gives a value of $30 in MS66 and $115 in MS67. This does not sound like a coin to send for grading. If it cost $25 to grade and came back as MS66, it would break even. I think it stands a chance at MS67, but then again, I'm no grader. Full resolution photos. All three coins from my order are taking their place in my album. This is a full set (excluding errors such as the 22 no D, 55 doubled die, and so on) and mint state except for the 1914-D. All cents from 1930 onward are full red. It's looking real good in its green Intercept Shield album. I won't be getting anything graded. If I did it wouldn't fit in the album, and then I would just have to replace it anyway. The question is, what do I do with the ones I've replaced?
As finding American coinage is scarce in Spain, I had to pick this up this morning from a coin shop. He took in a small collection of mixed countries and I paid 25 Euros for it. Possibly a little more above its value but couldn't resist.