Discussion in 'US Coins Forum' started by Allan, Jan 3, 2020.
The images are really bright. I'll bet the coin looks a bit darker in hand.
Log in or Sign up to hide this ad.
MS Details Cleaned but not a Straight MS like it graded
I personally don't see any wear in these images, and I don't see any harsh polish or cleaning lines. Absolutely, 100% the coin has been dipped and I personally don't find it attractive or appealing.
However, assuming that there is some luster in hand, an MS-60/61 grade is appropriate here.
This is an assumption...?!
Come on, ICG is not a “bargain basement TPG”. Are you aware that experts like Insider work there? As another member mentioned, they grade the coins according to their own standards.
I'm sorry that you missed the point. You took what I said at face value and lost the meaning.
Sorry, I think I did. What were you trying to say? It wouldn’t receive a straight grade if submitted to NGC/PCGS?
Yes and the grading company is not done in a basement or garage, it's just not one of the top 3. They have their own standards and they stick to them.
Separate names with a comma.