Reply to Thread

Message:: [QUOTE="coins776, post: 1662007, member: 45493"]i bought this coin in an ebay auction last year, i paid $57.66 for the coin. the seller did not list this coin as being a proof coin but the pcgs holder of the coin says PR GENUINE with surface damage. i sent the coin to a coin dealer last year and they told me that the coin is in fact[ATTACH]245405.vB[/ATTACH][ATTACH]245406.vB[/ATTACH][ATTACH]245407.vB[/ATTACH][ATTACH]245408.vB[/ATTACH] a proof coin but they did not want the coin because of the surface damage. i then sent the coin to an auction house and they sent the coin back to me and said that the coin is not a proof coin. i then contacted pcgs and provided photos of the coin to them. they said that the coin is a possible MS coin and that i could get a regrade of the coin. i figured it was not worth sending in the coin for a regrade and i sold the coin as just a regular 1832 half dollar (not a proof coin) to a coin dealer for $41.50. did i maybe sell a possible very rare coin for a very low price? i am sorry about the low quality of the photos of this coin. they are the best photos that i have of this coin. please give your opinions of this coin.  thank you[/QUOTE]