Reply to Thread

Message:: [QUOTE="vincent2920, post: 117264, member: 5138"]My first reply This is my first reply to a forum. I sent a 1913-s type 2 to PCI some time ago and it had very similar characteristics as the one you have , only mine had no toning. It came back as an au50. I have learned alot since then. I sent about 20 coins to PCI at the time. This was the first time I had ever sent coins to anyone for grading. I figured PCI was fairly cheap and I was curious about some of the coins I had. The buffalo you sent has too much detail missing  to be an MS. Hair around the horn is worn as is the the shoulder area. I'll let everybody know a little secret. I was probably one of the biggest fools in the past because most of the silver coins I have I dipped sometime in the past. I also dipped some buffalo's . When all the coins came back from PCI they were red-labeled cleaned except for the buffalo's. The other buffalo's I dipped now have the same toned look as the the one you posted. Good or bad ? They look great and I'm not sure anyone can tell they were dipped. Maybe yours was dipped in the past as well ?[/QUOTE]