My Morgan dollar type coin. Before: 1881-S, PCGS MS65. Common as a grain of sand on the beach, but Gem quality- nice bright white and lustrous. PCGS priceguide= $265 After: 1880-S, PCGS MS63 DMPL. Still a very common date, but Deep Mirror Prooflike and housed in a cool early PCGS slab that’s probably 30+ years old. Anybody know which generation it is? PCGS priceguide= $300 What do you think? Was the 65 to 63 drop worth it to get the DMPL? I think so.
Thanks for the link, Sal. It’s not Gen. 1.2 because that’s one of the old “rattlers”. It looks like it could be a 2.1, though, which would put it between October to December of 1989. Looks like if it had been slabbed just a month or two earlier, it would have been in one of the now-coveted Gen. 2.0 “Doily” holders, which would likely add $100 or so to the value just for the rare plastic. Just missed being a “Doily”!
I agree with @Seattlite86 100% Your new coin is something very special and not commonplace and ordinary
The OGH are my favorite, basic no frills and nostalgic but the grading seem to be a bit more conservative back then I have been on the hunt for a 1908 Saint OGH and just found a couple good choices that Iam considering, only issue I have is that on the certification they don’t show up on line because of the letters were changed to numbers and you have to actually call to get the info.
For me, it's more about what I like in appearance, so a lower grade or not, I'd go with the DMPL every time.
Yes it's a 2.1. It is also a scarce holder. It has the pcgs in the outer ring. Just not as coveted as the doily. There's nothing so special about the doily that should make its coin worth 10x as much as any other.