Horrible Ebay experience

Jack, your gonna be at the ANA show in milwaukee? Cool, i hope to make it up there on friday and saturday.

 

Log in or Sign up to hide this ad.

I did not tell you to take a hike and you had every opportunity to respond back and say that my offer was unacceptable to you.

I am being honest. I sincerely believe that this coin is MS65PL.

I bought this coin off ebay late last year. I could have returned it, but I did not even consider it because I liked the coin. In no way was I trying to pass along a "bad buy".

I am sorry that you think you were ripped off. I sincerely believe that this is MS65PL. I could not and cannot see the wear that you are referring to...but to show my good intentions on clearing up this matter, I am now going to send you $60. Basically down to my price.

I have owned a large number of solid DMPL and PL morgans. Early this year I sent an 1880-S to NGC and it came back MS65PL when I only graded it MS64PL. I've also owned a considerable number of raw dmpl and pl's that I sold. No disrespect intended, but believe me, I know what a prooflike morgan looks like. I do try to participate in this hobby in the right way and by no means did I intend to rip anyone off. If $45 would have resolved the matter, $60 should be even better. :hug:

 

more refund

Dan,
Of course $60 is better. Keep raising your offer, LOL, I'll take it!!!

If you honestly think that the coin is a MS-65 PL, I have the CDN in front of me: bid is $600. So, in otherwords, a refund of about $140 ( I said I would pay your fees ) and your going to pass up a coin you " honestly " grade a 65 pl? Honest? Really? Think about it. Honest? Hmmmm, $600 / $140, wow, hard decision. Honest? Really?

This is getting fun the more I get to know you, you squirm like I did at your age. But, reputations are heard to lose, and in this hobby / trade, I sure would not want to get a bad one. The $140 would probably hurt you alot more than it will me, but the $$$ is the least of it. Integrity and principle are worth much more than a quick profit on a coin.

Hmmm, Go figure.

 

$600 for a MS65PL? That would be MS65DMPL.

 

That's for DMPL...not PL. A distinct difference. That's why I asked in an earlier thread where the price guide was/is for "PL" coins, as I have not seen one. I have '84 CC PCGS MS65PL, and I can't find anyone who wants it for a decent price because, while DMPL is in most price guides, a coin with a PL designation is not.

Oh yeah, I bought it raw on eBay for CDN AU bid...

 

elsewhere

Wow, unbelievable. Thought this was a blog, LOL.

 

I can see I'm in the wrong place. Good luck & have fun, all!

 

Check sent, received, and feedback mutually removed.

 

I am glad to see that all are happy now.
Thanks, DJ, for keeping us all up to date, and good luck.